axis (political language)
A one-dimensional moral scale, with a good pole and a bad pole, along which a political tribe organizes and expresses its view of issues (e.g., oppressor/oppressed, civilization/barbarism, freedom/coercion).
As defined in Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “axis (political language)” →
- Much punditry, when examined closely, is not an attempt to open the minds of one's own side or the other side, but rather to close the minds of people on one's own side—and the axes are the tool for doing so because framing an issue along the tribal axis makes allies feel settled and praises the pundit as smart.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- Political ideologies organize good and bad along three distinct axes: Progressives use oppressor/oppressed (good = aligning against oppression), Conservatives use civilization/barbarism (good = accumulated civilized values that pass the test of time), and Libertarians use freedom/coercion (good = free individual choice, bad = government coercion at gunpoint).Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- An economist who disciplines themselves never to leave the economic camp and never rely on the axes will have diminished status within any tribe; this explains why Gary Becker, who does more economics on his blog, has perhaps 1/100th of Paul Krugman's followers despite both being Nobel laureates, because Becker is unwilling to play to the axes the way Krugman does.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- The three axes are not fundamental explanations of why people hold their political views; rather, they predict how people will be most comfortable expressing their points of view and processing their beliefs, functioning as the language a tribe uses to communicate.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- When someone disagrees with you, the natural habit is to place them at the opposite end of your single axis, but in reality opponents are often orthogonal to you—operating on a different axis entirely—which is a place they would never put themselves.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics
- Applying an axis to an issue is appropriate when it genuinely fits (e.g., oppressor/oppressed for the fight against Jim Crow), but the framework's power and its danger is that most people force every issue into their respective axis, even nuanced issues that cannot be reduced to such simplistic terms.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics