astrology
The practice of interpreting the positions and movements of celestial bodies (stars and planets) as determining or influencing human affairs and destiny; condemned by Augustine as incompatible with human free will.
As defined in The Bible and Western Culture - Part 1 - Augustine and the Christian Self
Where it comes up · 3
- AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London7 claims
- Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook4 claims
- The Bible and Western Culture - Part 1 - Augustine and the Christian Self1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “astrology” →
- Astrology, astronomy, and alchemy represent nascent forms of science and astronomy respectively, so dismissing them with contempt overlooks that the dreamers behind them had intuitions about phenomena worth investigating, even if their methods were crude.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- Augustine's argument against astrology (a component of Manichaeanism) was that two people born at the same moment under identical celestial conditions had vastly different fates, proving that the stars do not determine human destiny.The Bible and Western Culture - Part 1 - Augustine and the Christian Self
- The literal claims of astrology—that planetary positions affect human personality and destiny—are intellectually bankrupt and can be disproven in an hour by finding unrelated children born simultaneously with different fates.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- You can give a charitable psychological reading to astrology exactly as you give to religion, showing that both express deep truths about human nature, making distinctions between them difficult.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- We could be in a world where cathedrals had stained-glass windows with zodiac signs, as Christianity and astrology were nearly integrated at points in history, so the choice to preserve Christian cathedrals rather than astrological ones is partly historical contingency rather than rational necessity.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- Religion should be placed among bad ideas worth retiring because it makes the same sorts of unfalsifiable claims as astrology, and both convince believers to hold superstitious worldviews that can cause harm.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- If you examine the emergence of astrology within Christianity and find that Christianity incorporated astrological symbolism, this does not make astrology more credible but rather shows how Christianity absorbed and reinterpreted existing superstitions.AD Harris/Murray/Peterson Discussion: London
- The Western rationalist attitude is not the only possible epistemology and is in many ways a prejudice needing correction; the older Chinese civilization thought differently, and only through Heraclitus in Western philosophy (or in astrology, alchemy, and mantic procedures) do we find approaches comparable to the Chinese correspondence principle that the West has largely lost.Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
- The astrological experiment showed that unconscious biases and calculation errors in Jung's analysis all tended to exaggerate results in favor of astrology, demonstrating the synchronistic involvement of the observer's psyche in affecting experimental outcomesCarl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
- Synchronistic phenomena are found with some degree of regularity and frequency in intuitive magical procedures (I Ching, geomancy, astrology) where they are subjectively convincing but extremely difficult to verify objectively and cannot be statistically evaluatedCarl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook