as if
Friedman's methodological argument that unrealistic assumptions are acceptable if agents behave as if the assumptions were true and the model predicts well.
As defined in Paul Pfleiderer on the Misuse of Economic Models
Where it comes up · 2
- Paul Pfleiderer on the Misuse of Economic Models2 claims
- Russ Roberts and Mike Munger on Wild Problems1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “as if” →
- A core error Roberts came to recognize is conflating economic models with reality: economists like Friedman taught that people act 'as if' they optimize because it predicts behavior, but somewhere economists came to believe that constrained maximization is what people actually do—and Roberts now argues it is neither what they actually do nor what they should do.Russ Roberts and Mike Munger on Wild Problems
- Friedman's 'as if' argument—that assumptions need not be realistic so long as agents behave as if they were—should not be used to shield chameleon models from criticism of their assumptions when those assumptions have no intersection with the real world.Paul Pfleiderer on the Misuse of Economic Models
- The 'as if' argument works for the pool player and the fly-ball catcher because they get a million-plus repetitions with near-instantaneous feedback in a structured environment; it fails for decisions like corporate capital structure where the decision is rare, the feedback is slow and ambiguous (requiring the stock market itself to be solving the equations), and experts can't even agree on the model.Paul Pfleiderer on the Misuse of Economic Models