artificial purpose
A goal created by stipulation, as in a game, that gives rise to a structured activity even though the goal itself is arbitrary and not practically necessary.
As defined in Purpose, Pleasure, and Meaning in a World Without Work (with Nicholas Bostrom)
Where it comes up · 2
- 385 - Ai Utopia2 claims
- Purpose, Pleasure, and Meaning in a World Without Work (with Nicholas Bostrom)1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “artificial purpose” →
- Games are the model for creating artificial purpose: by setting an arbitrary goal (like getting a golf ball through holes in sequence using only a club), one generates an activity in which to exercise skill and derive pleasure—and nothing prevents creating elaborate artificial purposes at technological maturity, distinct from real purposes that involve things you actually need to do.Purpose, Pleasure, and Meaning in a World Without Work (with Nicholas Bostrom)
- Most people already get satisfaction not from the real consequences of failing at work but from arbitrary self-imposed challenges like golf, where you could simply place the ball in the hole but instead master hitting it with a stick—satisfaction comes from mastery and present-moment attention, not from any meaning beyond the activity, so this psychology already describes most people alive.385 - Ai Utopia
- In a solved world one can manufacture purposeful striving by defining goals to include the constraint that they be achieved on one's own steam without technological aids—just as a mountaineer who wants to reach the peak unaided cannot achieve it by being airlifted—so by baking constraints into objectives, arbitrarily complex single- or multiplayer games can generate genuine opportunities for striving and skill development.385 - Ai Utopia