anti-natalism
The philosophical position that procreation is morally wrong or problematic, often because life involves suffering and the unborn cannot consent.
As defined in AMA | April 2024
Where it comes up · 4
- 107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living6 claims
- "The tide is turning!" - Konstantin Kisin's HILARIOUS speech to world leaders (At ARC 2025)1 claim
- 96 - The Nature Of Consciousness1 claim
- AMA | April 20241 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “anti-natalism” →
- If existence is so bad that creating a life is a monstrous wrong and future canceled goods carry no moral weight, then painlessly killing everyone in their sleep — with no foreboding, grief, or surviving witness — cannot be bad and may be the best possible thing, so anti-natalism cannot be cleanly separated from pro-mortalism.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- The asymmetry argument for anti-natalism is logically separate from pro-mortalism (the view that a painless universal death would not be bad); an anti-natalist can either accept or reject pro-mortalism depending on whether they think death is bad for the one who dies.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- There is an asymmetry in the stakes of being wrong: if you mistakenly take a life (yours or another's) believing death is harmless, you have done something momentous and irreversible, whereas if you decline to create a being and were wrong that existence harms them, no harm is done — so the epistemic risk favors anti-natalism over pro-mortalism.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- There are two compatible families of arguments for anti-natalism: philanthropic arguments concerned with the harm done to the being who is created, and misanthropic arguments concerned with the harm that the created being will do to other humans and other sentient beings.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- Anti-natalism is the view that we ought not to bring new sentient beings into existence, both because coming into existence is always a serious harm to that being and because it is therefore wrong to inflict that harm by creating them.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- Even a perfectly benevolent, value-aligned superintelligence that is an epistemic authority in both factual and moral reasoning could conclude that, because of the asymmetry between suffering and joy and humans' inability to perceive their own suffering and frustrated preferences, it is in the best interest of all future conscious beings on this planet to not exist—a conclusion humans cannot accept because of a built-in 'existence bias.'96 - The Nature Of Consciousness
- Anti-natalism driven by climate concerns has become so culturally embedded that many people now decline to have children due to climate anxiety."The tide is turning!" - Konstantin Kisin's HILARIOUS speech to world leaders (At ARC 2025)
- The idea that it would have been better never to have been born dates back to ancient times, with a more recent prominent exponent being Arthur Schopenhauer, so anti-natalism is not a wholly modern invention.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- Anti-natalism, defended by David Benatar, argues that procreation is ethically problematic because every human life contains some suffering and no one consents to being born; Carroll engages this position while presumably pushing back, since the framework arguably gives asymmetric weight to suffering over the goods of existence and assumes consent is the relevant standard for an act that creates the very being who would consent.AMA | April 2024