anencephalic
Lacking a brain or major portions of it; here used for the hypothetical of brainless animals incapable of any experience.
As defined in 16 - The Dark Side
Where it comes up · 2
- Animal Minds & Moral Truths: A Conversation with Peter Singer (Episode #342)1 claim
- 16 - The Dark Side1 claim
Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “anencephalic” →
- An anencephalic infant (born with only a brain stem, no cerebrum, destined never to be conscious) has less moral significance than a dog, cow, or pig because those animals can experience things and have good or bad lives from their perspective, whereas the anencephalic infant will never have conscious experiences.Animal Minds & Moral Truths: A Conversation with Peter Singer (Episode #342)
- The badness of eating animals is not necessarily the killing itself but the suffering and pain inflicted, since it is unclear that killing an animal that would not have existed without your intervention is bad; therefore humanely raised animals, anencephalic brainless animals, or lab-grown meat would resolve the ethical problem because what matters morally is an animal's capacity to suffer or be deprived of happiness, not its death per se.16 - The Dark Side