analog computer
A computing device that represents data as continuous physical quantities (voltages, positions, rotations) rather than discrete binary digits, and solves problems by manipulating these analog quantities through circuits or mechanical systems
As defined in History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)
Other definitions
A computer that represents quantities with continuously varying physical values, such as rotations or voltages, rather than discrete digital states.
#95 Claude Shannon
Where it comes up · 3
- History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)6 claims
- Stephen Marglin on Markets and Community 03/10/20082 claims
- #95 Claude Shannon1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “analog computer” →
- The 1930s-40s socialist calculation debate treated markets as an analog computer: Lange and Lerner argued that a planner could simulate market allocation on paper through trial-and-error price signals, which assumes all knowledge is algorithmic; Hayek countered that much relevant knowledge is experiential, tacit, and revealed only when people must act.Stephen Marglin on Markets and Community 03/10/2008
- Economists regarded Hayek as the loser of the socialist calculation debate, and the subsequent development of general equilibrium theory reinforced the view that markets are merely an analog computer, while the market's real strength is mobilizing invisible experiential knowledge.Stephen Marglin on Markets and Community 03/10/2008
- Analog computers (mechanical, electronic, photonic) represent an alternative paradigm where computation is performed on continuous variables represented by physical states rather than bitified (discretized) representations, exemplified by slide rules, Kelvin tide-predicting machines, and potentially modern photonic quantum computers.History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)
- Analog computers are limited for non-linear systems because the mapping of non-linear differential equations to linear electronic circuits is difficult; this limitation was a primary reason analog computers were abandoned for general-purpose digital computing.History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)
- Kelvin's tidal computing machine mechanically added rotating wheels with different periods to compute tides, analogous to Ptolemaic epicycles; the machine exploited the fact that tides are sums of multiple periodic components.History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)
- Less than a decade after Shannon's thesis, the analog differential analyzer was effectively obsolete, replaced by digital computers that could do its work literally 1,000 times faster and answer questions in real time, a design descending from Shannon's discovery.#95 Claude Shannon
- The Antikythera device (~100 AD) is an ancient analog computer with gearing mechanisms that can be moved to any angle; while it has teeth (giving it a somewhat digital appearance), it is fundamentally analog because gear ratios determine rotational rates continuously.History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)
- Slide rules (using logarithmic scales) have been used since the 1600s as analog computers, where physical distance on scales represents multiplication through logarithmic properties—a mechanical analog computing paradigm that remained useful until electronic calculators arrived in the early 1970s.History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)
- Electronic analog computers from the 1980s used passive LRC (inductor-resistor-capacitor) circuits to solve differential equations; differential equations from physical systems (springs, bouncing balls) could be mapped to circuit equations, allowing the physical circuit to simulate the system.History of Science and Technology Q&A (February 8, 2023)