all-seeing eye
Felin's shorthand for the implicit assumption that scientists occupy an omniscient vantage point from which they can judge what actors should perceive or do.
As defined in Teppo Felin on Blindness, Rationality, and Perception
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “all-seeing eye” →
- Edith Penrose's critique of Alchian captures the core problem: it is unreasonable, except for professional pride, to endow economists with omniscience and prescience while denying it to entrepreneurs, since both operate under uncertainty using their own theories to make sense of situations.Teppo Felin on Blindness, Rationality, and Perception
- Simon's bounded rationality and Kahneman's bias program specify human perception as a bounded or blind range, but doing so covertly grants scientists an omniscient all-seeing position from which they declare what humans miss—an unwarranted asymmetry that ignores that real actors are theoretical beings directing attention via a search image.Teppo Felin on Blindness, Rationality, and Perception
- Telling people they made the wrong choice under uncertainty by invoking expected value neglects that a risk can cost someone sleep and wellbeing, so it is presumptuous for a scientist or policymaker to override another's risk preferences—an extension of the unwarranted omniscience assumption.Teppo Felin on Blindness, Rationality, and Perception