all lawful use
A contracting demand that a vendor permit any legally permissible use of its product; the speakers argue it is abnormal in procurement and question-begging because 'lawful' is itself contested.
As defined in Claude, War, and the State of the Republic (with Dean Ball)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “all lawful use” →
- 'All lawful use' is an abnormal and question-begging notion in defense procurement; a contract for a missile does not say it can be used for all lawful use, so the Department of War's position pretends contracts are something they are not, and 'lawful' is itself undefined—effectively the administration decides what is lawful until courts stop it.Claude, War, and the State of the Republic (with Dean Ball)
- After Senate confirmation in fall 2025, Department of War official Emil Michael reviewed the contract, decided the Department could not live with the surveillance and autonomous-weapons restrictions, and demanded renegotiation for 'all lawful use only'; Anthropic dropped many restrictions but held those two as red lines.Claude, War, and the State of the Republic (with Dean Ball)