aggregation problem
The error of treating a positive net effect on a whole population ('the United States benefits') as if it justified a policy, ignoring that some individuals are made worse off.
As defined in Michael Lind on Libertarianism
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 1 of 1Search all claims for “aggregation problem” →
- It is a form of utilitarianism—unattractive from a Hayekian/Austrian view—to claim that because the net gain to all Americans from a policy like immigration reform is positive, it is therefore a good idea; a positive aggregate does not follow into a good policy because it won't make everybody better off, and the CBO-style nuanced report of small real gains and real wage losses at the bottom gets distorted into 'America will grow rich and nobody will suffer.'Michael Lind on Libertarianism