affective polarization
Polarization measured by how negatively people feel about the opposing party and how strongly they identify with their own, regardless of actual policy disagreement.
As defined in 81 | Ezra Klein on Politics, Polarization, and Identity
Where it comes up · 3
- Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics, Revisited3 claims
- 81 | Ezra Klein on Politics, Polarization, and Identity3 claims
- 233 | Hugo Mercier on Reasoning and Skepticism1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “affective polarization” →
- When identities that once cut across parties (union members, religious groups, races, regions) stack on top of each other and align with party, the nature of disagreement becomes deeper and more threatening, making affective polarization—fear and hatred of the other side and loyalty to one's own—a rational response.81 | Ezra Klein on Politics, Polarization, and Identity
- There are distinct kinds of polarization—policy polarization (parties clustering at opposite policy poles) and affective polarization (how negatively people feel about the other party)—and affective polarization, driven by hatred and fear of the other side, has risen much more than actual policy disagreement.81 | Ezra Klein on Politics, Polarization, and Identity
- In the US the average Republican and Democrat are much closer on actual policy positions than people believe; what is clearly growing is affective polarization—increasing mutual dislike—driven partly by greater ideological coherence, so that knowing someone's party now lets you infer disagreement on many issues and gives grounds to dislike them.233 | Hugo Mercier on Reasoning and Skepticism
- Much partisan attachment is driven less by loyalty to one's own party than by fear of the other party—many Republicans dislike Trump but hate the Democrats, and many Democrats dislike their party but fear Trump's re-election—so out-group fear is a primary motivator of political behavior.81 | Ezra Klein on Politics, Polarization, and Identity
- Adam Smith argued in The Theory of Moral Sentiments that it matters more to us that our friends hate what we hate than that they like what we like; sharing a positive opinion brings mild pleasure if reciprocated, but a friend liking something we find awful upsets us far more, which prefigures affective polarization's emphasis on shared antipathy.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics, Revisited
- Affective polarization—pure love for one's own side combined with hatred of the other side—is distinct from issue polarization (taking opposite positions on specific issues like gun control or abortion), and its usage as a concept is rapidly accelerating in political psychology.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics, Revisited
- When people feel frustration with leaders on their own side (e.g., a Republican who dislikes Trump), their psychological response is to hate the other side more, because intensified out-group hatred reduces the cognitive dissonance of belonging to a side whose leaders they dislike.Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics, Revisited