abiogenesis
The natural origin of life from non-living matter; 'abiogenesis number two' refers to a second, independent origin of life used as a benchmark in experiments.
As defined in 106 | Stuart Bartlett on What "Life" Means
Where it comes up · 14
- 286 | Blaise Agüera y Arcas on the Emergence of Replication and Computation4 claims
- 47 | Adam Rutherford on Humans, Animals, and Life in General4 claims
- 106 | Stuart Bartlett on What "Life" Means3 claims
- 323 - Science Survival2 claims
- Adam Frank2 claims
- 6 | Liv Boeree on Poker, Aliens, and Thinking in Probabilities2 claims
- 86 | Martin Rees on Threats to Humanity, Prospects for Posthumanity, and Life in the Universe2 claims
- AMA | March 20252 claims
and 6 more
Most important claims · 10 of 27Search all claims for “abiogenesis” →
- Finding any kind of life with an independent origin on Enceladus or Europa would have the momentous implication that life's origin was not a rare fluke—if it happened twice independently in our solar system, it must have happened in a billion places in the galaxy—whereas life found on Mars would be ambiguous because meteorites can carry material between Mars and Earth.323 - Science Survival
- Life is incredibly ordered and structured, and while it does not strictly violate the second law of thermodynamics because energy must go in to metabolize, ordered living structure is permitted but not exactly encouraged by thermodynamics, which is what makes the emergence of life mysterious.286 | Blaise Agüera y Arcas on the Emergence of Replication and Computation
- The fact that life started fairly early on Earth is essentially meaningless as evidence for the probability of life forming, because we must conditionalize on the fact that life already exists—we already know that, so it doesn't tell us much about the underlying per-planet odds.259 | Adam Frank on What Aliens Might Be Like
- Science cannot explain how you get from a rock to a living organism; the standard 'primordial soup' answer glosses over the most important step—how matter began reproducing with function and complexity—and humans are deeply under-equipped to understand the origin of life.Paul Rosolie #2
- Evidence for life arising independently on other worlds would require either: (1) detection of radio/light signals, (2) laboratory reconstruction of a simple abiogenesis pathway from inorganic compounds to cellular replication, or (3) empirical discovery of multiple independent abiogenesis pathways—but it's harder to prove the negative (that life is rare) because prebiotic conditions are vastly diverseA billion years of evolution in a single afternoon — George Church
- Conversations with researchers like Blaise Agüera y Arcas support a growing credence that basic life is, if not inevitable, highly likely in any environment permitting sufficient complexity; the relevant Fermi 'paradox' bottleneck may lie not at abiogenesis but at later transitions like multicellularity or sentience.AMA | March 2025
- Even if life turned out to be extraordinarily rare (e.g., unique in 10^23 star systems), this would not necessarily license abandoning likelihood-based explanations for life's origin in favor of improbable chance events, because anthropic selection means we necessarily observe a system where life arose, so rarity is compatible with a low-probability-per-system mechanism without invoking Boltzmann-brain-like flukes.AMA | March 2025
- Because computation is a numerical attractor, life wants to form and will form whenever it has a chance, the opposite of Francis Crick's view of life as a near-miraculous improbable event, suggesting we should expect to find evidence of life as we explore places like the moons of Jupiter or use better telescopes.286 | Blaise Agüera y Arcas on the Emergence of Replication and Computation
- Of the Drake Equation factors, the fraction of planets that develop life carries by far the largest uncertainty—on the order of 200 orders of magnitude—because abiogenesis is so poorly understood, so cutting off the fringe parts of that fat-tailed distribution and assuming a middle value is bad math that claims knowledge we don't have.6 | Liv Boeree on Poker, Aliens, and Thinking in Probabilities
- The 'great filter' is some insurmountable barrier in the evolutionary chain that most planets cannot pass; Boeree intuits it lies around the transition from prokaryotic to eukaryotic life—getting a nucleus into the cell—and notes that intelligent life appeared only about five-sixths of the way through Earth's lifespan, suggesting the rarity is largely about how long these transitions take.6 | Liv Boeree on Poker, Aliens, and Thinking in Probabilities