Zomia
A term (borrowed from Pierre Clastres via James C. Scott) for the vast mountainous highland zone across southwest China and southeast Asia where peoples historically evaded state control.
As defined in Dan Wang
Where it comes up · 2
- The US vs China in the 21st Century3 claims
- Dan Wang2 claims
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Zomia” →
- Highland Southeast Asia, which includes southwestern China, is a zone where peoples historically fled state taxation, conscription, and surveillance, and Wang's Yunnan family roots mean Yunnanese have libertarian attitudes, which James C. Scott's Art of Not Being Governed illuminates.The US vs China in the 21st Century
- Highland Southeast Asia, including southwestern China, Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, and northern Thailand, was a region where peoples ran from states because of conscription, taxation, grain assessment, and disease, and this evasion continues today among Yunnan and young Chinese who move to Chiang Mai.The US vs China in the 21st Century
- Top-down systems like China's can outperform in the near term, but their roots are shallower, so they are more fragile over the long run than bottom-up systems, which James C. Scott's work supports, though Scott's Zomia research shows the dynamic of people escaping the state in mountainous Southeast Asia.The US vs China in the 21st Century
- James C. Scott's best work, The Art of Not Being Governed, describes Zomia—a heavily mountainous southwest-China/southeast-Asia zone larger than Western Europe where people hid from the Burmese, Tibetan, and especially Han Chinese states, practicing 'escape agriculture' by planting hidden underground or high-elevation crops like cassava, potatoes, and maize rather than legible grains, and maintaining strong oral cultures and ethnic malleability to evade the state.Dan Wang
- A key difference between the US and China, Japan, or Europe is that the US is much more governed by its Zomia-like rural residents who hold some contempt for elite high culture, with rulers (especially the House of Representatives) quite removed from what would be considered high culture—because American cities never served the civilizing functions that cities did elsewhere in the world.Dan Wang