Tyranny of the majority
The problem that, under collective decision-making, the majority's preferences prevail and minorities get something other than what they want.
As defined in Joel Waldfogel on Markets, Choice, and the Tyranny of the Market 11/12/2007
Other definitions
The danger that a numerical majority in a democracy will use its power to oppress or override the rights and interests of minorities.
Terry Moe on the Constitution, the Presidency, and Relic
Where it comes up · 4
- Joel Waldfogel on Markets, Choice, and the Tyranny of the Market 11/12/20075 claims
- The Very American Roots of Trumpism | The Ezra Klein Show2 claims
- Terry Moe on the Constitution, the Presidency, and Relic1 claim
- George Will on the Conservative Sensibility1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “Tyranny of the majority” →
- Madison revolutionized democratic theory by rejecting the idea that democracy requires a small homogeneous society; since the worst outcome is tyranny of the majority, the solution is to prevent stable tyrannical majorities by fostering ephemeral, constantly shifting coalitions of minorities in an extensive republic, protecting the unequal capacities of acquiring property to produce a saving multiplicity of factions.George Will on the Conservative Sensibility
- There is a key distinction between two situations. In the first, people who share my preferences help me get products while people with different preferences don't hurt me; this is a 'who benefits whom' effect that is only remotely like tyranny. In the second, people with different preferences actually reduce what is available to me, which is the true analogue of the tyranny of the majority.Joel Waldfogel on Markets, Choice, and the Tyranny of the Market 11/12/2007
- In markets with large fixed costs, a consumer gets what they want only if many other people share their preferences. Markets therefore do not fully escape the 'tyranny of the majority' that critics attribute to politics, contrary to Milton Friedman's claim that each person can 'vote' for the tie color they want and get it.Joel Waldfogel on Markets, Choice, and the Tyranny of the Market 11/12/2007
- Daily newspapers are the extreme case. A typical US city has essentially one metropolitan daily, and that single product must choose whom to target. The more people who like one thing, the more it targets them and the less appealing it becomes to others, which is genuinely analogous to political tyranny of the majority.Joel Waldfogel on Markets, Choice, and the Tyranny of the Market 11/12/2007
- The Founders were essentially aristocrats and propertied people who feared tyranny of the majority, did not believe all men are created equal, and designed a Constitution partly to ensure that they and people like them would continue to control the government.Terry Moe on the Constitution, the Presidency, and Relic
- Alexis de Tocqueville's Democracy in America, though normally read as a document establishing America's inevitable ascent into liberal democracy, actually contains extensive warnings about where America could be headed, particularly around slavery, racism, and the tyranny of the majority in local politics that could rapidly push the United States toward despotism where people would surrender rights to a strong man.The Very American Roots of Trumpism | The Ezra Klein Show
- Alexis de Tocqueville's Democracy in America, commonly read as a celebration of America's inevitable liberal-democratic ascent, actually contains extensive warnings about potential despotism, particularly centered on slavery, racism, the tyranny of the majority, and the possibility that Americans would quickly surrender rights to a strong man.The Very American Roots of Trumpism | The Ezra Klein Show
- The political process often imposes a single uniform level where nothing inherent requires it. Examples are the uniform national postal price and public schools, though schooling can be supplemented with private lessons or private schools. In such cases the tyranny of the majority is a political choice rather than an inevitability.Joel Waldfogel on Markets, Choice, and the Tyranny of the Market 11/12/2007
- Some goods are inherently provided at a single level for everyone, such as missile defense or the size of the US Army. For these, whether provision is public or private (private provision being hard because of free riding), the tyranny of the majority is unavoidable.Joel Waldfogel on Markets, Choice, and the Tyranny of the Market 11/12/2007