Treatise on Money
An earlier major work by Keynes, reviewed scathingly by Hayek in Economica, which Keynes himself later conceded was flawed and had moved beyond.
As defined in Nicholas Wapshott on Keynes and Hayek
Where it comes up · 2
- Nicholas Wapshott on Keynes and Hayek2 claims
- Zach Carter1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “Treatise on Money” →
- The Hayek-Keynes debate was poisonous from the outset—Hayek's review of Keynes's Treatise on Money in Economica was a scathing, sarcastic, blanket condemnation reading more like nasty blog posts than traditional academic critique, and this vituperative tone set the pattern for the next 80 years of debate between the two intellectual sides.Nicholas Wapshott on Keynes and Hayek
- Keynes effectively repudiated his Treatise on Money, since there would have been no need for The General Theory if the Treatise had been right; the Treatise's ad hoc, knotted justification for public works as a one-time necessity reflects Keynes tying himself in knots to justify a policy preference, though its discussion of chartalism and the rise of capitalism is essential to ideas later developed in The General Theory.Zach Carter
- Keynes did not fully counter Hayek's critique of the Treatise on Money partly because he had already conceded the book was flawed and had moved on to writing a better book, stating in the Preface that his mind was constantly changing on the subject and the work was just thinking aloud.Nicholas Wapshott on Keynes and Hayek