Timelines (short vs. long)
Predictions about when AI systems will reach human-level or superhuman capabilities; 'short timelines' means 2-10 years, 'long timelines' means 10+ years or decades
As defined in AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “Timelines (short vs. long)” →
- When communicating about policy and technical AI work, one should aim for intellectual honesty about timelines and risks; the 'slow world' compartmentalization is defensible in personal life but not in professional/policy contexts where truth-telling is primaryAI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- Long-term projects that take years to pay off (PhDs, research programs, papers) may be difficult to justify if timelines are genuinely short (2-5 years), creating a problem: we need long-term projects but individuals are psychologically averse to them under short-timeline beliefAI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- Sarah defends compartmentalization as not denial or intellectual dishonesty, but as psychologically healthy: she can believe short timelines are plausible while planning personal life and relationships as if longer timelines are realAI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- A significant downward adjustment in AGI timelines has occurred across multiple independent groups: Metaculous prediction markets are trending downward, AI lab researchers report increasingly short timelines, and even the more conservative AI Impacts survey of machine learning researchers has shifted from ~2060 (2022) to ~2040 (present), suggesting genuine evidence beyond groupthink.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- There are two distinct psychological states or 'worlds' people can inhabit regarding AI timelines: a 'fast world' where one constantly monitors AI progress and feels urgency about near-term transformative change, and a 'slow world' where one maintains psychological equilibrium by living as if normal timelines apply and planning accordingly.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- If emotional relationships are devalued because one believes nothing long-term matters, one suffers genuine emotional impoverishment: friends' successes (engagements) become less joyous to witness and loved ones' suffering matters less, indicating that myopic thinking about timelines has intrinsic emotional costs beyond practical ones.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- The best approach to AI timelines may be scenario planning across multiple timeline assumptions rather than precise timeline predictions, because predicting exact dates is unreliable and can create 'crying wolf' problems, whereas planning for multiple scenarios preserves options.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- Believing timelines are short but planning for long-term outcomes (PhD, savings, career investments) is practically rational because if timelines are actually longer, one will regret not having invested in those outcomes, whereas if timelines are short, having those investments won't hurt.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- Initial anxiety about AI safety (in Sarah's own case, 2023 onwards) can transform into interest and inspiration through community engagement, reducing the emotional burden from obsession to constructive engagement—this suggests that emotional dysregulation around timelines isn't inevitable but depends on how you frame the work.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- Even well-intentioned researchers making hedged predictions about timelines may face social pressure to be more confident for communicative impact, creating a ratchet toward overconfident public statements even among honest people.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)