TFP
Total Factor Productivity—the portion of economic output growth not explained by increases in labor and capital inputs, often taken as a proxy for technological and knowledge progress.
As defined in Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress
Where it comes up · 5
- Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress5 claims
- Esther Duflo3 claims
- AGI is still 30 years away — Ege Erdil & Tamay Besiroglu2 claims
- Dan Wang1 claim
- Simon Johnson1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “TFP” →
- U.S. Total Factor Productivity over the last 150 years shows lowish growth, then a real growth spurt mid-20th century, a much lower level since around 1970 with a slight peak near 2000 attributed to the ICT revolution, and now historically low levels again—a pattern consistent with mid-century science working very well and the rate of discovery being lower since.Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress
- There is no clean temporal separation where invention precedes deployment; technological progress is an interplay between having ideas and building, learning, and producing (learning curves) — nobody 20 years ago had the blueprint for 2025 solar panels, and aircraft depended on prior smelting improvements, so capital accumulation and complementary inputs are intrinsic to discovery itself, not just downstream of it.AGI is still 30 years away — Ege Erdil & Tamay Besiroglu
- Rather than taking a firm stand on whether aggregate progress is slowing, the strong claim is that the rate of scientific progress is declining very rapidly on a per-person, per-hour, and per-dollar basis—aggregate progress may be sustained only because of enormous, qualitatively exponential increases in investment and effort that cannot be sustained indefinitely.Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress
- The Bloom, Jones, Van Reenen and Webb paper 'Are Ideas Getting Harder to Find?' shows that per-person and per-dollar research productivity is declining within specific fields like drug discovery, semiconductors, and crop yields—and declining exponentially at surprisingly consistent rates—with no strong refutation appearing since its preprint.Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress
- R&D is genuinely important and necessary but is less important in relative terms than other inputs (capital, labor), none of which alone is sufficient for growth; just as you can't reach a Dyson sphere by scaling only labor and capital, you also can't reach it by scaling only TFP — you must scale everything at once, and credit attribution should follow factor elasticities (labor ~0.6, capital ~0.3).AGI is still 30 years away — Ege Erdil & Tamay Besiroglu
- Declining per-scholar productivity does not mean innovation has stopped; in the Moore's Law case, chip capacity keeps improving, but it takes an enormously larger number of researchers to produce each improvement, so it is the per-researcher rate that is falling, not the overall level of innovation in the field.Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress
- Much digital technology since the 1970s was deployed not because it boosted productivity but because management thought it would displace workers; Acemoglu and Restrepo's 'so-so technology'—exemplified by supermarket self-checkout kiosks that shift work onto consumers without raising worker productivity or wages—explains why technological change has coincided with weak TFP growth and widening inequality.Simon Johnson
- US geographic mobility has fallen (to about half its 1948 level, with decline starting in the 1990s) because economic shocks are geographically clustered—when a region's clustered industry is hit, all local businesses suffer, real estate prices collapse, and people become underwater on their homes—and because moving means abandoning social networks and entering a different, often demeaning sector where one starts from scratch and loses the meaning derived from long-held expertise.Esther Duflo
- Possible explanations for declining per-person productivity fall into three classes: the nature of reality (low-hanging fruit picked, and lowest-hanging scientists already chosen), poorly organized search for knowledge (universities and labs needing overhaul), and bad rules of the game in society (legislation and cultural norms hampering productivity)—and these factors get tangled together.Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress
- Politicians should treat growth as a useful 'chief of staff' rather than something to fall in love with, because growth rates are hard to manipulate (especially fluctuations), so when a country fixates on restoring growth instead of asking why it fell, leaders try increasingly desperate measures and back themselves into bad macroeconomic corners—as Japan did with debt-financed Keynesian spending that built up an unnecessary debt level without actually restoring growth.Esther Duflo