Somewheres versus Anywheres
A distinction (coined by David Goodhart) between 'Somewheres'—people rooted to a particular place who stay there and derive identity from it—and 'Anywheres'—mobile, educated people who feel they can live and belong anywhere.
As defined in Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Somewheres versus Anywheres” →
- Any viable way forward for a nation must be rooted not in abstract principles but in visceral, particular attachments, because people can argue themselves out of abstract principles as easily as into them, whereas the elemental loyalty of 'these are your mates' cannot be so easily reasoned away.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
- The Brexit vote was driven not by hostility toward immigrants or economic concerns but by a desire for control and a need to know who could be trusted; voters who stay rooted in a place resent those who leave because departures deplete the shared social capital of that community.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
- The morality of standing by your friends regardless of who is right ('because they're your mates') seems foreign to the educated professional class, but in fact elites act this same way in practice (e.g., journalistic pile-ons) while refusing to profess it aloud; this particular loyalty is more powerful and more necessary to human flourishing than the Anywheres admit.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
- There is no such thing as a pure universal brotherhood of man; humans are always bound in the end by extremely particular attachments to a particular place, a particular home, a particular people, and a particular way of life.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
- The Anywhere conception of a nation as a hotel—a service provider where you pay for the amenities you want and any redistribution is animated solely by universalist humanitarian goals—is fundamentally unworkable and is in fact unappealing even to the people who espouse it, who simultaneously lament the global homogenization of places.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
- The British monarchy retains the people's affection because the assertion of national identity and togetherness is the principal duty of the Crown; the royal family is the essence of 'Somewhere'—you cannot get more Somewhere than Buckingham Palace—which is why the Somewheres are especially attached to it.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
- The pandemic demonstrated the primacy of particular attachments because the 'Anywheres'—globally mobile people who believed they could go anywhere—found themselves trapped somewhere, revealing that national borders mattered more than any other affiliation.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity
- What is most disturbing about contemporary America is that the Anywheres have in some fundamental way seceded from the country, forming their own little nation within a nation and now fighting a rhetorical civil war with the rest of the country, while the Somewheres have reacted in equally disturbing ways such as disputing legitimate election procedures.Megan McArdle on Belonging, Home, and National Identity