Semi-protected (Wikipedia)
A Wikipedia status applying additional editing controls on anonymous users for contentious articles to limit vandalism or edit wars.
As defined in Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “Semi-protected (Wikipedia)” →
- Cognitive surplus is the reconception of leisure time—the ~20 hours/week of TV watching per person, aggregating to roughly a trillion hours/year in the industrialized world—as an aggregate raw material that can be designed around; Wikipedia consumed only ~100 million hours total (less than Americans spend watching ads on a single weekend), making such projects explainable as harnessed surplus requiring only invitation and reward rather than recruiting and management.Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- The web privileges effectiveness over efficiency, allowing organized behavior at scales impossible to manage institutionally: Wikipedia's editorial culture (~2 million English contributors, ~5 million across languages) is roughly 100,000 times larger than its managerial culture—an inversion of a newspaper, where the managerial culture (all employees) is about twice the editorial culture.Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- Nupedia's failure demonstrates that grafting the institutional transaction-cost model onto the web doesn't work: its seven-step expert workflow created seven points of potential stalling, and as a voluntary effort it produced only about a dozen articles in nine months—whereas Wikipedia succeeded by replacing organized process with massive perennial peer review where everything is provisional.Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- A key reason institutional projects stall is that gatekeepers with veto power enjoy that doing nothing means nothing happens; Wikipedia's success came from NOT giving experts veto power—a deliberately simplistic article ('asphalt: material used to cover roads') triggers others to say 'I can do better,' so articles improve from a provisional seed rather than waiting indefinitely for the ideal expert.Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- Social science explanations of collaborative phenomena must become largely probabilistic ('cloudy with a chance of collaborations') because social life involves many complex feedback loops making it more like predicting weather than gravity—even with full knowledge of inputs, predictability is far lower than the neoclassical model hopes, and such phenomena get stuck in special cases (you couldn't recreate Wikipedia with identical inputs because Wikipedia already exists).Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- When we observe organized behavior we wrongly assume an organization is directing it, but phenomena like Wikipedia pages are organized without an organizer—an instance of what Hayek called emergent order.Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- Economists pre-2000 would have predicted Wikipedia could not work because of the free-rider problem—everyone would happily read it but no one would create it without profit or glory; they were wrong because they misunderstood the pure pleasure (plus small private non-monetary returns like comments and recognition) that overcomes free-riding, making such voluntary contribution a massive positive social externality unprecedented in human history.Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- Wikipedia's success in lowering transaction costs simultaneously opens it to system-gaming (e.g., editing of the Sarah Palin article before her VP announcement), forcing it to back into governance models (semi-protection, edit-war handling) that balance open participation against abuse—making the Wikimedia Foundation effectively 'the experimental wing of political science.'Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008
- Calling Wikipedia a 'positive externality' reveals a theory not working hard enough: the externality of Wikipedia is in fact the business/economic value it creates, while the social effects are internal to the transaction—so internalizing non-financial motivations would better explain what is going on, and Wikipedia will stop being viewed as an externality.Clay Shirky on Coase, Collaboration and Here Comes Everybody 10/20/2008