Right to Repair
A movement and proposed legislation asserting that owners of products must be allowed to repair them rather than being forced to rely on manufacturers.
As defined in 341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle
Other definitions
A legal and political movement asserting that owners (and independent shops) should be allowed to repair products they own rather than being locked into manufacturer-controlled service.
The Unseen Work: Stewart Brand on Maintenance and Civilization
Where it comes up · 3
- The Unseen Work: Stewart Brand on Maintenance and Civilization2 claims
- 464 - The Politics Of Pragmatism And The Future Of California2 claims
- 341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Right to Repair” →
- California's construction defect liability laws are so litigious and expensive—allowing suits a decade after a building is finished over trivial issues, creating a profit center for trial lawyers—that developers no longer build condos, leaving California with the lowest home ownership rate in the country, 10% below the national average, by eliminating the most accessible entry point to ownership.464 - The Politics Of Pragmatism And The Future Of California
- John Deere, historically beloved for dedication to customers, has become the poster child of the Right to Repair fight because it locks the software in precision agriculture into a closed garden, forces farmers to use distant dealers, and remotely cripples tampered machines so they can only limp back to the barn--an attitude that may not survive the century even though sequestered repair is its most profitable activity.The Unseen Work: Stewart Brand on Maintenance and Civilization
- John Deere does not need legislation to correct its repair-locking; though it gained short-term profitability from controlling repairs, it has tremendously damaged its brand, and the market will likely punish that if it loses its dominant position.The Unseen Work: Stewart Brand on Maintenance and Civilization
- The right-to-repair movement holds that if you buy and own a device you must be able to fix it—otherwise you don't really own it and shouldn't have paid a purchase price; companies like John Deere, once famous for repairable tractors, now make repair difficult and expensive to extract more income, but this is short-term gain that erodes long-term customer loyalty.341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle
- California no longer builds condos because construction-defect liability laws are so expensive—a building can be sued 10 years after construction because paint is bubbling or chipping, turning defects into a profit center for trial lawyers rather than something simply repaired—so new multi-family housing is almost always built for rent, contributing to California having the lowest homeownership rate in the country, 10% below the national average.464 - The Politics Of Pragmatism And The Future Of California