Problem situation
In Dewey's epistemology, a situation in which habitual behavior proves inadequate or blocked; the encounter with a problem that interrupts fluid experience and provokes thought; the stimulus for intelligent, experimental thinking.
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
Other definitions
Dewey's term for a concrete experience of disruption or uncertainty that initiates inquiry; similar to Whitehead's 'event' but emphasizing the problematic character of lived experience
A History of Philosophy | 64 American Pragmatism
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Problem situation” →
- When driving on flat roads habitually, one doesn't think about the mechanics of driving; but driving on steep hills with stop signs at the top creates a problem situation that demands thought—one must devise alternative strategies (such as using the emergency brake and clutch to stop on the incline).A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
- Values are non-moral goods used as instruments for survival; survival itself is non-moral, yet it becomes loaded with value in certain problem situations; ethics concerns how to solve problems and achieve what we desire—it is an instrumentalist ethic.A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
- When facing an unfamiliar problem situation—like finding a broken bridge blocking the path to a job interview—one must conduct mental experiments: imagining walking upstream to find another bridge, estimating distance and time; or practicing long jumps on the side to test feasibility of jumping the creek.A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey
- A problem situation is dialectical: the thesis is the interrupted fluid experience; the antithesis is the threatening or blocking situation; the synthesis is the right idea that enables one to embrace both and move forward, becoming the thesis for the next dialectical cycle.A History of Philosophy | 65 John Dewey