Precautionary principle
A decision rule for situations lacking sufficient evidence: reject or restrict an action whose potential downside is catastrophic and irreversible until evidence of safety accumulates.
As defined in Nassim Nicholas Taleb on the Precautionary Principle and Genetically Modified Organisms
Other definitions
A decision rule stating that if an action might cause harm to the environment or public health, the burden of proof should be on those proposing the action, not on those opposing it; one should be cautious when uncertain about harmful outcomes
A conversation between Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Stephen Wolfram at the Wolfram Summer School 2021A regulatory stance that treats a new substance as potentially harmful until shown safe, used in the EU for novel chemicals.
Justin Mares - The US Health Crisis - [Invest Like the Best, EP.333]
Where it comes up · 24
- Nassim Taleb - The #1 Rule to Not Be a Sucker (The Ergodicity Principle)4 claims
- Nassim Taleb — Meditations on Extremistan3 claims
- Nassim Nicholas Taleb on the Precautionary Principle and Genetically Modified Organisms3 claims
- A conversation between Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Stephen Wolfram at the Wolfram Summer School 20212 claims
- Judith Curry on Climate Change2 claims
- Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Rationality, Risk, and Skin in the Game2 claims
- Marc Andreessen on Why AI Will Save the World2 claims
- 329 - What Happened To The Republican Party2 claims
and 16 more
Most important claims · 10 of 37Search all claims for “Precautionary principle” →
- The precautionary principle in its strong versions (placing the burden on a proponent to prove an activity is safe) is incoherent and paralyzing because it forbids the very steps it requires: banning nuclear power on precautionary grounds itself creates probabilistic risks (including climate change), so the principle simultaneously compels and prohibits action, inaction, and everything in between.Cass Sunstein on Worst-case Scenarios 11/19/2007
- The key lesson for the next pandemic is to apply the precautionary principle and act fast under uncertainty—do everything when you don't know what you've got—but then remain highly responsive to early data and adjust interventions to the specific pathogen's characteristics, since there are no guarantees about what the next one will be.141 | Zeynep Tufekci on Information and Attention in a Networked World
- The scientific establishment failed not because randomized trials are wrong but because it lacked the flexibility to match the research method to the question and the risk involved; for low-downside interventions like masking, the precautionary principle plus mechanistic science plus the South Asian experience were sufficient, whereas for high-stakes interventions like vaccines, more rigor was appropriate.Zeynep Tufekci
- The precautionary principle rests on asymmetry: when there is uncertainty about something where the downside is ruinous (e.g., a pilot of uncertain skill, possibly-poisoned water, climate, or GMOs), the rational response is to avoid the action rather than demand proof of harm, because the burden of the asymmetry means 'no evidence of harm' is not 'evidence of no harm.'Nassim Taleb - The #1 Rule to Not Be a Sucker (The Ergodicity Principle)
- We should apply the same precautionary approach to the scope of the moral circle that we apply to other high-stakes uncertain policy domains: the question should not be whether a being definitely or even probably matters, but whether there is a realistic, non-negligible chance it matters for its own sake given the best available evidence—and if so, we should give it at least some moral consideration in a spirit of caution and humility while investigating further.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- Technology policy should be based on the proactionary principle—constantly evaluating technologies based on evidence of how they are actually used and what actually happens—rather than the precautionary principle, which restricts based on imaginary harms to a third person.Kevin Kelly on Advice, AI, and Technology
- The precautionary principle applies to climate policy: if there is uncertainty about climate models, the rational response is to stop activities that could cause harm (reduce pollution, shift to alternatives), rather than waiting for proof of climate danger, because the downside of being wrong is catastrophic.Nassim Taleb - The #1 Rule to Not Be a Sucker (The Ergodicity Principle)
- A modest carbon tax (equivalent to perhaps $3/gallon on gasoline) is justified on precautionary grounds because there is roughly a 5% — not black-swan — probability of a catastrophic outcome; just as we spend heavily to make air travel safe rather than accept a 1% crash risk, a small-but-significant chance of severe climate damage warrants paying an insurance-like cost.Robert Pindyck on Climate Change
- Imposing large costs on the private sector causes deaths because people become poorer and less employed; data suggest roughly a $7 million expenditure causes at least one statistical death, so a $40 million regulatory expenditure (not unusual) probabilistically causes five or six or more deaths, which itself violates the precautionary principle.Cass Sunstein on Worst-case Scenarios 11/19/2007
- Europe assumes novel chemicals are potentially harmful until proven safe, while the U.S. assumes they are mostly safe and relies on companies' self-reported safety studies, which is why these chemicals are so pervasive.Justin Mares - The US Health Crisis - [Invest Like the Best, EP.333]