Planetary boundaries
Scientific framework identifying nine critical Earth system processes that have safe operating limits for human civilization (climate change, biodiversity loss, land use change, freshwater use, nitrogen/phosphorus cycles, ocean acidification, ozone depletion, atmospheric aerosols, chemical pollution); exceeding boundaries increases catastrophic risk.
As defined in Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
Other definitions
A framework positing fixed environmental thresholds that humanity must not surpass; one of several guises of the carrying-capacity idea.
Charles C. Mann
Where it comes up · 3
- Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 20236 claims
- Charles C. Mann2 claims
- The Dark Side of Conscious Ai | Daniel Schmachtenberger2 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Planetary boundaries” →
- Concepts of fixed ecological limits—carrying capacity, planetary boundaries—are intuitively appealing but very hard to substantiate because ecology, like macroeconomics, studies huge systems with countless poorly-understood moving parts, and both fields are afflicted with elegant models that are adhered to far more than they are empirically tested.Charles C. Mann
- While the earth is finite and some limit to food production must exist, the location of that limit is essentially unknown; the pessimist case can be simultaneously true and irrelevant—if the limit is so distant that it never binds, the pessimists are technically right but it doesn't matter, and given that demographers expect world population to level off around 9-12 billion without doubling again, optimists can declare victory if everyone is well-fed and comfortable by around 2070.Charles C. Mann
- Pfoa (fluorinated surfactants/forever chemicals) are now present in rainwater globally including Antarctica at levels above EPA and EU safety thresholds, affecting not just human health but soil microbes and algae, representing a crossed planetary boundary with unknown cascade consequences.Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
- AI alignment cannot be reduced to aligning AI systems with human values because human intentions are themselves often misaligned—with each other, with long-term human flourishing, with other species, and with planetary boundaries—making it necessary to first achieve greater human consciousness integration and collective alignment before delegating optimization to AI systemsThe Dark Side of Conscious Ai | Daniel Schmachtenberger
- A financial system requiring exponential growth to avoid collapse through interest payments is fundamentally incompatible with biosphere sustainability because exponential growth eventually hits planetary boundaries, but the system requires 3% more money every year regardless of actual goods and services available.Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
- From an economic perspective, AI and software appear to solve planetary boundaries by enabling exponential economic growth without proportional resource consumption, creating dangerous incentive to accelerate AI development without adequately addressing dual-use and existential risks.Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
- We are at the end of human civilization defined by the characteristic that power-oriented civilizations with greater violence capability consistently destroy peaceful alternatives, a dynamic that has defined all of written history from Egypt to Sumeria forward and is now incompatible with exponential technology at planetary boundaries.Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
- People who engage in deep contemplative practice (meditation, medicine journeys, philosophical reflection) may experience direct contact with fundamental meaningfulness that transcends their narrow personal interests and connects them to care for the whole, and this type of experience is essential for motivated engagement with solving systemic problemsThe Dark Side of Conscious Ai | Daniel Schmachtenberger
- Physics and biology set hard constraints that cannot be negotiated or changed, whereas human history is based on institutions that have adapted; being realistic about planetary boundaries requires being 'unrealistic' to human institutional history.Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
- Norskin Foundation has invested in North Volt to create 'the world's greenest batteries' using renewable energy, but this does not solve fundamental problems of whether impact investment can address a $100 trillion/day system driving planetary boundaries.Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023