Performance Standard
A regulation that specifies a required outcome (e.g., maximum emissions) and lets firms find the cheapest way to meet it or pay a fine, without dictating the technology.
As defined in Bruce Yandle on Bootleggers and Baptists
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Performance Standard” →
- The crucial regulatory question is not merely whether to regulate but what form regulation should take: a centralized top-down technology mandate forecloses innovation and can produce perverse outcomes, whereas a performance standard (specifying a result and letting firms find the cheapest way to meet it or pay a fine) preserves competition, innovation, and lower costs.Bruce Yandle on Bootleggers and Baptists
- Whenever you observe a technology-based standard rather than a performance standard, you should be highly suspicious that bootleggers are hidden behind the scenes and Baptists are working to get that specific technology specified into law.Bruce Yandle on Bootleggers and Baptists
- Regulators are not neutral parties: a technology-based standard makes enforcement trivially easy (the device is either present or not), whereas a performance standard requires the regulator to measure and monitor actual outcomes—so regulators also have an incentive to prefer technology mandates.Bruce Yandle on Bootleggers and Baptists
- Politicians prefer technology mandates partly because they can claim credit for a visible artifact—pointing to a mandated scrubber and saying 'without it this smokestack would be dirtier'—whereas a performance standard's benefits accrue to unknown future innovations that cannot be easily pointed to or claimed.Bruce Yandle on Bootleggers and Baptists
- Because of concentrated benefits and dispersed costs, technology-based standards let politicians target the delivery of a visible benefit to identifiable groups (who know they received it) while the costs are spread thinly across all consumers as small increments on power or product bills that nobody notices—whereas performance standards diffuse benefits competitively and cannot be claimed for credit.Bruce Yandle on Bootleggers and Baptists