PISA
Programme for International Student Assessment—standardized tests used to compare actual learning across countries' school systems.
As defined in Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty
Where it comes up · 8
- Lant Pritchett on Education in Poor Countries6 claims
- Eric Hanushek on the Education, Skills, and the Millennium Development Goals5 claims
- Eric Hanushek on Education and Prosperity2 claims
- Lant Pritchett on Poverty, Growth, and Experiments2 claims
- Esther Duflo1 claim
- Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty1 claim
- Nicholas Crafts, Luis Garicano, and Luigi Zingales on the Economic Future of Europe1 claim
- Gerd Gigerenzer on How to Stay Smart in a Smart World1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 19Search all claims for “PISA” →
- Years spent in the classroom is a very imperfect measure of population skills because measured test performance reveals huge gaps: the difference between students in Peru and Singapore amounts to roughly five years of schooling, so a 9th grader in Peru performs like a 4th grader by Singapore standards despite identical recorded attainment.Eric Hanushek on the Education, Skills, and the Millennium Development Goals
- The post-2015 development goal should keep the 8th/9th year of schooling standard but require that students at the end demonstrate a basic skill level (PISA Level 1)—a form of functional literacy needed to compete in international labor and product markets—rather than measuring inputs like years of attendance alone.Eric Hanushek on the Education, Skills, and the Millennium Development Goals
- Education aid may not promote economic growth—and could even lower measured income short-run as working children switch to school—because, as Lant Pritchett documents, so little actual learning occurs in low-quality school systems (measured by PISA scores rather than 'rear ends in seats') that an additional year of schooling in some countries may never promote growth.Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty
- The political economy of reform is binding because society is old—the median voter is around 50—so even badly needed reforms like fixing Spain's poor education system (terrible PISA results, weak universities) fail to resonate, as the median voter prioritizes health and pensions over education, demonstrating that voters are as rational as economists grant them.Nicholas Crafts, Luis Garicano, and Luigi Zingales on the Economic Future of Europe
- Projections across 76 countries show that for middle-income countries, getting the remaining ~20% of students into 8th/9th grade at current quality is worth roughly double current GDP in present value, while taking the 80% already in school and lifting the bottom up to Level 1 is worth about six times GDP, and doing both yields about thirteen times GDP—demonstrating that improving learning matters far more than merely adding seats.Eric Hanushek on the Education, Skills, and the Millennium Development Goals
- U.S. student achievement, as measured by international tests, is considerably below that of other developed countries and many developing countries, with the U.S. ranking slightly below the OECD average on the PISA test.Eric Hanushek on Education and Prosperity
- The French education system is very good at producing and reproducing a very small elite of highly educated people, but current PISA and TIMSS results show France at the median overall with high heterogeneity—excellent results at the top, very poor at the bottom—and the strongest OECD correlation between socioeconomic class and math scores, indicating the historically excellent, inclusive system has been allowed to crumble.Esther Duflo
- On the 2009 PISA exam, the two Indian states tested (chosen as the country's best) scored around 320 against an OECD mean of 500 with a 100-point student standard deviation, meaning the average Indian 8th-grader would land in the bottom 1-percentile if placed in a Danish or US school—and this almost certainly overstates India-wide performance.Lant Pritchett on Poverty, Growth, and Experiments
- On the PISA assessment run by the OECD, the average score of the higher-performing Indian states India agreed to enter would place the typical Indian child in the bottom 2% of an American classroom — an unbelievably large performance gap.Lant Pritchett on Education in Poor Countries
- Direct household testing by Pratham (the ASER survey) in Indian villages — bypassing schools where results were falsified or based on rote repetition — found that a substantial portion of children completing grade 5 could not read any words at all, and most could not read a simple grade-2 story, implying they had learned almost nothing despite reaching grade 5.Lant Pritchett on Education in Poor Countries