MOND
Modified Newtonian Dynamics, a proposal to modify the law of gravity/dynamics at low accelerations to explain galactic rotation without dark matter.
As defined in AMA | November 2025
Where it comes up · 8
- 359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy4 claims
- 245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics3 claims
- AMA | February 20212 claims
- 240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe1 claim
- AMA | November 20251 claim
- AMA | October 20231 claim
- Holiday Message | Hits and Misses1 claim
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | July 20261 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “MOND” →
- Anyone who claims to eliminate dark matter with a new theory but only cites spiral galaxy rotation curves as evidence can be instantly dismissed, because rotation curves were the best evidence in the 1980s but are no longer; the cosmic microwave background, large-scale structure, baryonic acoustic oscillations, galaxy clusters, and gravitational lensing now form a whole suite of evidence, so the decisive challenge is whether the theory predicts the CMB power spectrum.AMA | February 2021
- Milgrom's MOND was motivated by a near-universal acceleration scale at which galaxy rotation curves transition from needing no dark matter to needing it, and that acceleration is numerically approximately equal to the present Hubble parameter, a coincidence that seemed to connect galactic dynamics to cosmic expansion.359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy
- When someone claims to replace dark matter with modified gravity by talking about spiral galaxy rotation curves, you can stop listening, because the best evidence for dark matter is no longer galaxies and clusters but the cosmic microwave background, whose pattern of acoustic peaks provides quantitatively superior, predicted-in-advance evidence for dark matter specifically.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- Modified gravity theories that successfully fit the CMB, like Bekenstein's TeVeS, do so only by adding new fields (vector and scalar degrees of freedom) that carry energy and create a gravitational field independent of ordinary matter; that is, by definition, dark matter — so calling it modified gravity is just a labeling choice that produces a weird, broken, hard-to-understand version of dark matter.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- Both the regime where dark matter becomes necessary in spiral galaxies and the regime where cosmic acceleration sets in share the common feature that gravity is weak — the relevant acceleration scale in galaxies is numerically similar to the Hubble constant and the cosmological constant — which motivated trying to modify general relativity so that it behaves normally when spacetime is curved but deviates when spacetime becomes nearly flat.Holiday Message | Hits and Misses
- Weakly interacting massive particles remain the most likely dark matter candidate because the electroweak mass scale (100-1000 GeV) naturally hosts a new neutral particle that would be a great dark matter candidate; the only reason for skepticism is that searches have so far ruled out roughly half the feasible parameter space without a detection, while axions and superfluid/other light particles have risen in credence and MACHOs and MOND are essentially ruled out by baryon constraints and observations like the Bullet Cluster.AMA | February 2021
- A criticism of the modified gravity community is that they tend to focus on particular observations they can explain rather than the full gamut of available data, and even within galaxies there are many observations modified gravity struggles to explain—though focusing one's work is itself sometimes necessary.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- Modified gravity theories like MOND that were meant to eliminate dark matter have been ruled out by cosmic microwave background anisotropy predictions, so they no longer work, though a few researchers keep working on them.359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy
- Dark matter and dark energy have not been directly detected and are inferred from spacetime behavior, so they could in principle be artifacts of modifying gravity on cosmological scales, though MOND is now ruled out by cosmic microwave background data.359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy
- There is a legitimate reason people pursue modified gravity: MOND predicts a real, observed relationship between ordinary matter and dark matter in spiral galaxies (a characteristic radius inside which dark matter is not needed) that is not directly explained by the dark matter hypothesis; however, the difficulty of explaining a feature is far weaker than modified gravity's fatal problem of being ruled out by data.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics