Laplacian demon
A hypothetical intelligence that, knowing the positions and velocities of all particles, could compute the entire past and future; used to contrast particle-level computation with pattern-level prediction.
As defined in 78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
Other definitions
A hypothetical intellect that, knowing the precise state and laws of the universe, could compute its entire past and future.
AMA | December 2023
Where it comes up · 3
- 318 - Physics Philosophy1 claim
- 39 - Free Will Revisited1 claim
- 78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “Laplacian demon” →
- A woman who overhears a phone call can predict that two people will arrive within thirty minutes with a bottle of wine just by understanding the meaning of what was said, whereas a Laplacian demon tracing every photon and trajectory would find the same prediction miraculous—showing the explanatory power of higher-level pattern descriptions over particle-level computation.78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
- There is a theoretical limit to predicting an agent's behavior: Donald MacKay showed that a Laplacian demon cannot predict your behavior if it is going to interact with you, because then it must predict its own behavior too, requiring a complete self-description that, as Turing showed, you cannot have — so the perfect-predictor scenario faces an in-principle obstacle, not just a technological one.39 - Free Will Revisited
- Being predictable does not make an agent less free; on the contrary, the more strongly motivated and decisive you are, the more predictable and the more free you are. We can confidently predict someone will choose crème brûlée over broken glass precisely because they are freely acting on their preferences, and Leibniz held God—the freest being—is the most predictable because he will always choose the best.318 - Physics Philosophy