Landauer's principle
The principle, conjectured by Landauer and proven more rigorously by Bennett, that erasing a bit of information has an irreducible thermodynamic cost because it maps all possible states into one blank state.
As defined in 167 | Chiara Marletto on Constructor Theory, Physics, and Possibility
Where it comes up · 3
- 192 | Nicole Yunger Halpern on Quantum Steampunk Thermodynamics4 claims
- AMA | March 20212 claims
- 167 | Chiara Marletto on Constructor Theory, Physics, and Possibility1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “Landauer's principle” →
- There is a real difference between erasing a memory and a memory not yet having been created: erasing (like pouring water over a footprint) is an irreversible entropy-increasing process where you can't recover the past, whereas running time backward removes the footprint by lowering entropy along the trajectory it came from, so Landauer's principle does not symmetrically apply toward the past.AMA | March 2021
- The Second Law that entropy increases follows from two things: the statistical definition of entropy (high-entropy macrostates correspond to vastly more microstates) plus a boundary condition of low entropy at one end of time, which we define to be the past; there is no pre-existing definition of past and future beyond the direction of lower versus higher entropy.AMA | March 2021
- Using constructor-theoretic principles, one can prove that the set of states of a system from which thermodynamic work can be reliably and deterministically extracted must be perfectly distinguishable (orthogonal, in quantum terms); this connection between useful work and distinguishability is established without appealing to any entropy-like or scale-dependent considerations, unlike the traditional Landauer-Bennett link between information erasure and thermodynamic cost.167 | Chiara Marletto on Constructor Theory, Physics, and Possibility
- Maxwell's demon appears to violate the second law by sorting fast and slow molecules to create a temperature difference and extract perpetual work, but the resolution (Bennett, building on Szilard and Landauer) is that the demon accumulates information in its memory and must erase it to truly reset the system; since Landauer showed that erasing information costs thermodynamic work, the erasure cost equals the work gained, netting zero and forbidding perpetual motion.192 | Nicole Yunger Halpern on Quantum Steampunk Thermodynamics
- Erasing information increases entropy and costs thermodynamic work (Landauer's bound sets a minimum entropy created per erased bit), which is why irreversible computations heat up our laptops; reversible computation is possible but would require idealized systems running impractically slowly, so real-world computers are far more wasteful than Landauer's limit.192 | Nicole Yunger Halpern on Quantum Steampunk Thermodynamics
- Despite Bennett's widely accepted resolution, there is still legitimate debate over whether it is fully satisfactory—for example, what if the demon had a very large ledger and didn't need to erase it for a long time—and over 100 years later the question has not been completely nailed down.192 | Nicole Yunger Halpern on Quantum Steampunk Thermodynamics
- Theorists have a reputation for proposing experiments that are impossible for the next 20 years, but Yunger Halpern has been pleasantly surprised at how often experimentalists respond that they can actually do a proposed experiment and offer to collaborate—evidenced by recent realizations of the Landauer ratio experiment on multiple platforms and the near-feasibility of Szilard's engine.192 | Nicole Yunger Halpern on Quantum Steampunk Thermodynamics