Intellectual Dark Web
A loosely defined group of public figures, popularized by a Bari Weiss New York Times article, characterized as people who say things that provoke progressives, particularly about biology, sex differences, and evolution.
As defined in 3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
Other definitions
A loose group of intellectuals (including Peterson, Harris, Shapiro) who reach the public through podcasts and videos and share criticism of progressive social-justice positions.
53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
Where it comes up · 9
- 53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality3 claims
- 180 - Sex Power2 claims
- 121 - White Power2 claims
- Steven Pinker: Progress, Despite Everything2 claims
- Jordan Peterson1 claim
- White Privilege1 claim
- 112 - The Intellectual Dark Web1 claim
- Ask Me Anything 121 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “Intellectual Dark Web” →
- Suppressing conservative and taboo views on campus (IQ, race, gender differences) conceals certain truths and prevents people from developing intellectual antibodies to bad ideas, so when someone first hears seemingly honest talk on a taboo topic from a figure like Jared Taylor, they slide into indoctrination—making the primacy of free speech an essential value the left is dangerously losing.121 - White Power
- Saying things that irritate progressives or provoke pushback does not make someone special as an intellectual; people have pushed back against controversial claims for decades, and social media merely intensifies and accelerates that reaction without changing its fundamental nature.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- What unites the Intellectual Dark Web is independence: each has their own funding source, so there is no bureaucratic master, and YouTube/podcasts give anyone a television station with no bureaucratic intermediation—politicians and anyone with something useful to say can bypass the press entirely, an opportunity people have barely begun to exploit.Jordan Peterson
- Independent long-form conversations (the so-called 'intellectual dark web') already reach millions, with figures like Joe Rogan reaching tenfold the prime-time audience of CNN; the absence of a time limit dictates a different, less guarded exchange of ideas, allowing even reputation-conscious mainstream figures to have more honest conversations.121 - White Power
- Tenure (academic job security) and independent means of support are crucial for intellectual independence; most members of the 'intellectual dark web' have either tenure or book sales providing financial independence from institutional pressure.Steven Pinker: Progress, Despite Everything
- The Intellectual Dark Web's self-description as a community for free good-faith dialogue with no biases is inaccurate because it is purely about methodology and conceals the substantive positions the group actually shares; honest intellectuals should be candid about the beliefs they want to spread.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- The claim that the IDW is dedicated to open free dialogue is not borne out by evidence—Jordan Peterson has threatened lawsuits over insults, called for departments to be shut down, planned a website to flag 'post-modern' courses, and bonded with Viktor Orbán over distaste for political correctness—and members like Peterson and Shapiro are sympathetic to climate skepticism and intelligent design, so the group is neither uniformly pro-free-speech nor pro-science.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- The intellectual dark web, coined by Eric Weinstein to name a media phenomenon of unedited podcast conversations garnering huge audiences, has been mischaracterized as conservative when it is actually a loose, mostly centrist and center-left group with only one real conservative, Ben Shapiro, united only by a commitment to speaking honestly on controversial topics.White Privilege
- What actually unites the IDW is the substantive position that unequal representation of groups (men/women, blacks/whites, gays/straights) in positions of power may reflect the natural order—an unbiased playing out of talents and inclinations—rather than bias or discrimination, effectively acting as apologists for the historically dominant group.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- A bright spot amid the breakdown is the emergence of the 'intellectual dark web'—roughly 25 people who, despite disagreements, are neither falling off the roof of reason into deplorable troglodytism nor being captured as dupes; with large social followings they can bypass the 'gated institutional narrative' (Harvard, NYT, the Senate) that once controlled coherence, forming a different substrate of conversation from which we may reboot.112 - The Intellectual Dark Web