Idiot index
Ratio of a finished product's cost to the cost of its raw materials; a high ratio signals large savings available through better manufacturing.
As defined in #399: How Elon Works
Other definitions
Ratio of a part's actual cost to the cost of its raw materials; a high ratio indicates excess process cost.
#414: How SpaceX Works
Where it comes up · 3
- #399: How Elon Works9 claims
- #414: How SpaceX Works3 claims
- #415: How Elon Thinks1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “Idiot index” →
- Great founders such as Carnegie and Musk stay in the details of cost, because costs can be strictly controlled and savings are permanent while prices and profits cycle with the market.#399: How Elon Works
- Musk used first-principles thinking, drilling down to basic physics and building up from there, which led him to the Idiot Index to compare a rocket's finished cost with the cost of its raw materials.#399: How Elon Works
- The idiot index is the ratio of a finished product's cost to the cost of its raw materials; a high ratio signals an opportunity to cut cost through better manufacturing, and engineers should know the worst parts by this measure.#415: How Elon Thinks
- Musk's idiot index is the ratio of a part's actual cost to the cost of its raw materials; a high ratio signals that the buyer is paying for process and overhead that could be eliminated.#414: How SpaceX Works
- Musk calculated that a finished rocket cost at least 50 times the cost of its basic materials, indicating an extremely high Idiot Index and large room for cost reduction through better manufacturing.#399: How Elon Works
- Musk argued a supplier's $120,000 part was no more complicated than a garage door opener and had an engineer build it for about $5,000, illustrating how supplier quotes can be drastically overpriced.#399: How Elon Works
- Musk pushed engineers to source components from non-aerospace industries, such as a $30 bathroom-stall latch replacing a $1,500 NASA latch, and to use commercial air conditioners in place of a $3 million custom system.#399: How Elon Works
- The raw materials cost of a rocket is around 2% of its typical price, a far lower ratio than cars (raw materials roughly 20-30% of sticker price) or consumer electronics, meaning about 98 cents of every dollar goes to something other than the material.#414: How SpaceX Works
- Musk challenged aerospace suppliers whose component prices were about 10 times higher than similar auto-industry parts, and he rejected standard industry practice by pushing manufacturing in-house.#399: How Elon Works
- A vendor quoted $120,000 and 18 months of development for a Falcon 1 actuator, while SpaceX's engineers built it for $3,900, showing how far outside-supplier pricing diverged from in-house cost.#414: How SpaceX Works