Hobbesian anarchy
A state-of-nature condition without overarching authority in which actors must defend themselves, after Thomas Hobbes.
As defined in Steven Pinker
Other definitions
The view, from Thomas Hobbes, that without a sovereign authority the world of states is a state of constant potential conflict.
The Lessons of History
Where it comes up · 3
- The Lessons of History2 claims
- Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei Talks Scaling Laws, AI Arms Races, and Radical Abundance1 claim
- Steven Pinker1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Hobbesian anarchy” →
- The modern state is designed to compete and organize itself for war, since protecting its individuals is its first task, and in a Hobbesian anarchic world of nation-states war is always looming, so it is only a matter of time before organizing for war returns.The Lessons of History
- International coordination on AI safety and security is extremely difficult because the international system is anarchic (no enforcer) and lacks mechanisms to enforce treaties or cooperation, making disarmament agreements unlikely to work without a solution to the fundamental coordination problem.Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei Talks Scaling Laws, AI Arms Races, and Radical Abundance
- There is no natural arc toward civilizational self-destruction; rather, as civilizations advance they tend to develop mechanisms that make conflict less likely, because war is stupid—you destroy things, kill people, and gain nothing you couldn't get otherwise, while belligerence gives others an incentive to destroy you—so a plausible trajectory is that advancing civilizations make war obsolete through world government or international norms, as a response to the Fermi paradox.Steven Pinker
- The United States' sufficient power has so far prevented the anarchic nation-state system from producing war, but this is not guaranteed to continue.The Lessons of History