Hadith
The collected sayings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad, a primary religious text in Islam alongside the Quran.
As defined in 11 - Shouldering The Burden Of History
Other definitions
Recorded sayings and traditions of the Prophet Muhammad that, alongside the Quran, form a source of Islamic law and doctrine.
Sam Harris on Jew-Hatred, Radical Islam, and the West
Where it comes up · 18
- Sam Harris on Jew-Hatred, Radical Islam, and the West2 claims
- 81 - Leaving Islam2 claims
- 298 - Leaving The Faith Rebroadcast2 claims
- 175 - Leaving The Faith2 claims
- 32 - The Best Podcast Ever1 claim
- 11 - Shouldering The Burden Of History1 claim
- 41 - Faith In Reason1 claim
- 31 - Evolving Minds1 claim
and 10 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “Hadith” →
- Unlike the Bible, which is largely a 'game of telephone' allowing textual reinterpretation, the Quran is regarded as the literal, perfect, and final word of God, leaving little room to finesse meaning; combined with the fact that Islam confronts modern science and human rights in one leap rather than the gradual centuries-long erosion Christianity and Judaism underwent, this makes reform far harder and gives the conflict a zero-sum character.81 - Leaving Islam
- The reformist project of moving Muslims along a continuum from conservative to liberal one reinterpretation at a time is not viable, because most Muslims treat their faith as a literal model for reality rather than a set of flexible cultural traditions; what reformers face are oppositional worldviews like heliocentrism versus geocentrism, where abandoning one for the other is easier than holding contradictory parts of both.81 - Leaving Islam
- The Islamic State is not the 'Scientology of Islam'—not a fringe cult—but offers an all-too-plausible version of Islam directly linked to the actual doctrine of jihad found in the Quran and hadith and to specific ideas about martyrdom and paradise, so the problem the Muslim world must grapple with is rendering that interpretation less plausible and less contagious.144 - Conquering Hate
- Liberal religious readings face a structural disadvantage to literalists: scriptures of the Abrahamic religions do not plausibly support modern values such as the moral equality of homosexuality or of women, so modernizers must bring 21st-century values to the text and cherry-pick against the plain meaning—a pantomime of scholarship in which one already knows the desired answer—leaving the literalist always able to say the apostates are not living by the letter of the text.41 - Faith In Reason
- Religious texts function as a 'software program for rebooting a worldview'; if Islam were lost and someone discovered the Quran, hadith, and biography of Muhammad and gave them a plausible, consistent, literalistic reading stripped of surrounding culture, they would 'reboot' something much like Wahhabism—totalitarian, intolerant, and unlucky for women—not Rumi, because the texts are less self-contradictory than Christianity or Judaism.32 - The Best Podcast Ever
- Maajid Nawaz's piecemeal approach of reinterpreting individual hadith through 'mental gymnastics' will ultimately fail because such reform attempts go back a millennium and you cannot change a single letter (harf) of the Quran; genuine reform would require a cataclysmic new revelation abrogating all violent passages.47 - The Frontiers Of Political Correctness
- Islam differs from other major religions in specific theological ways: its founder Muhammad was a warlord who won dozens of battles rather than a pacifist like Buddha or a crucified Jesus, and it carries a built-in expectation that the faith will be defended by force and will conquer the world in this life, giving it a different theological 'DNA' and set of expectations.Sam Harris on Jew-Hatred, Radical Islam, and the West
- If you described ISIS's behavior—sex slavery of Yazidis, beheading apostates, cutting off thieves' hands, killing fornicators and adulterers—and had to guess the underlying religion, no one would say Buddhism because the Pali canon yields nothing like it, but the letter of Islamic law makes complete sense of it, which is why al-Baghdadi is very difficult to argue is 'getting the religion wrong.'356 - Islam Freedom
- Wife-beating is a problem in Islam not because every Muslim man beats his wife, but because it is codified in scripture (chapter 4 verse 34), meaning men who do beat their wives have scriptural support and victims who complain are told the abuser 'has every right.'298 - Leaving The Faith Rebroadcast
- The official penalty for apostasy everywhere under Islam is death, supported by an explicit Hadith, so no one can be assured of safety in the worldwide Muslim community when changing their religion; this is why ex-Muslims who criticize Islam take genuine personal risk.Sam Harris on Jew-Hatred, Radical Islam, and the West