HHMI
Howard Hughes Medical Institute, a science funder known for longer-term, open-ended grants to investigators.
As defined in Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen
Where it comes up · 2
- Jonah Lehrer on Creativity and Imagine3 claims
- Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen2 claims
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “HHMI” →
- An MIT economists' study comparing the NIH to the Howard Hughes Medical Institute found that HHMI scientists—funded for avant-garde research with tolerance for failure—produced more home-run papers (more citations, more new scientific terms) but also far more total failures (papers with 0-1 citations), while equivalent NIH scientists, vetted by a rational process to avoid wasting taxpayer money, produced fewer of both; the lesson is you cannot get the big breakthroughs without tolerating the failures.Jonah Lehrer on Creativity and Imagine
- Pierre Azoulay's study found that among ostensibly identical scientists, those who received longer-term, open-ended HHMI grants were about twice as likely to produce a top-1%-by-citation paper as those who did not, which is suggestive—while controlling for selection effects—that open-ended funding structures better enable scientific discovery.Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen
- Cori Bargmann's theory is that the NIH and HHMI granting processes encourage individualistic work and fail to incentivize the collaboration people actually want; a concrete instance was that scientists building cell atlases for different body parts used incompatible data types and formats, so CZI's contribution was to coordinate teams and standardize data types so that individual grants would add up to a larger holistic Human Cell Atlas.Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen
- Because risk-taking is not in the DNA of government agencies like the NIH—whose accountability mandates produce more pretty-good, low-variance research—the conclusion should be less public investment if you want world-changing breakthroughs like cancer cures, which require the high-variance risk tolerance that government cannot supply.Jonah Lehrer on Creativity and Imagine
- The NIH funds more scientists who are exactly 70 years old than all scientists under 30 combined, while the Gates Foundation deliberately models itself on HHMI by funding risky possibilities and concentrating on scientists under 30 to correct for this age skew.Jonah Lehrer on Creativity and Imagine