GWAS
Genome-wide association studies; analyses that scan whole genomes across many individuals to find genetic variants associated with a disease.
As defined in 16 | Coleen Murphy on Aging, Biology, and the Future
Where it comes up · 6
- 165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness4 claims
- Gregory Clark1 claim
- A billion years of evolution in a single afternoon — George Church1 claim
- Marco Ramos on Misunderstanding Mental Illness1 claim
- Nick Lane1 claim
- 16 | Coleen Murphy on Aging, Biology, and the Future1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “GWAS” →
- The clean one-gene-one-illness model has not panned out for schizophrenia or bipolar disorder; newer GWAS approaches showing that changes across hundreds or thousands of genes can raise or lower risk represent some advance, but we remain miles away from any usable biomarker, and psychiatry should stop putting all its research eggs in this biological basket while waiting for a 'biological Godot' that may never arrive.Marco Ramos on Misunderstanding Mental Illness
- The known genetic causes of Parkinson's disease are far more limited than commonly assumed: only roughly 5% to 30% of Parkinson's patients have the disease due to a known gene, leaving most cases unexplained.16 | Coleen Murphy on Aging, Biology, and the Future
- Interpreting GWAS correlations faces two classes of problems: first, the measured SNP may not be the causal variant but merely co-inherited with it (requiring fine-mapping); second, people's genetics are correlated with their culture because mating is non-random across generations, so a gene-outcome correlation may reflect that the gene is simply more common in a culture that differs for environmental reasons (population stratification).165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness
- The best strategy for causal inference is comparing siblings rather than unrelated people, because which genes a child inherits from their parents is random; this natural experiment of children being randomized to genotypes conditional on their parents' genotypes unbraids genetic differences from the larger package of culture, environment, and geography, providing causal purchase analogous to a randomized control trial.165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness
- Even highly multigenic traits can often be controlled by very few changes: height involves on the order of 10,000 genes each with tiny effect, yet a single gene—growth hormone (somatotropin)—produces extreme low or high stature on its own and is used clinically, illustrating that reductionism can isolate a 'master switch' for complex phenotypes.A billion years of evolution in a single afternoon — George Church
- A polygenic score is a single number summing a person's DNA variants weighted by their estimated correlations with an outcome from a large discovery study; it is a biologically nonsensical grab-bag that collapses many different processes together, but it is no worse than other crude social science aggregates like socioeconomic status—in buying predictive power you sacrifice mechanistic specificity, so the challenge is to trace back to specific mechanisms.165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness
- Even outcomes that are obviously social and historically recent—like income or homelessness—can show genetic correlations because biology affects embodied traits (temperament, risk for serious mental illness) which are then refracted through a political and economic context; observing a genetic pattern correlated with income tells us which embodied characteristics and skills society currently rewards, letting researchers work backward to intervening processes.165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness
- Genome-wide association studies, even with up to 4 million genotyped people and a thousand identified loci affecting educational outcomes, still cannot mechanically locate the genetic basis we know exists from twin studies; combinatoric effects appear largely ruled out (effects are mostly additive), implying you may need samples larger than all of humanity to identify the rare permutations involved, and small populations like Native Americans may never be studyable this way.Gregory Clark
- Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) typically explain less than a tenth of the known genetic risk of diseases; rather than assuming millions of undiscovered weak SNPs account for the rest, the missing heritability may lie in the often-dismissed mitochondrial DNA, where a few single-letter changes control basic processes—illustrating how science persists with the wrong framing instead of noticing a whole missing system.Nick Lane