Fourth Amendment
The provision of the US Bill of Rights protecting people from unreasonable government searches of their persons, papers, homes, and effects, generally requiring a judicial warrant.
As defined in 347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
Where it comes up · 5
- 347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You4 claims
- Rachel Harmon2 claims
- AI Experts Debate: AI Job Loss, The End of Privacy & Beginning of AI Warfare w/ Mo, Salim & Dave 1762 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - The most important question nobody's asking about AI1 claim
- 213 - The Worst Epidemic1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Fourth Amendment” →
- The exclusionary rule has profoundly changed police culture by giving departments an incentive to teach officers constitutional law and officers an incentive to learn and follow it; before the rule officers knew nothing about constitutional law, after it every officer treats the Fourth Amendment as part of his manual—illustrated by a corrupt cop who still wouldn't fabricate probable cause because that was the part subject to the rule.Rachel Harmon
- Whether something counts as a Fourth Amendment 'search' turns on whether it violates a 'reasonable expectation of privacy' (established in United States v. Katz); your home clearly qualifies and requires a warrant, but it is an open question whether data you store with a third-party cloud provider like Google or Amazon still carries that expectation.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- Tech companies are not legally required to look for CSAM but must report it once aware, yet are only required to retain the material for 90 days; because overwhelmed law enforcement often cannot act in time, the evidence is frequently deleted before investigators arrive, producing dead ends and hampering AI classifier training.213 - The Worst Epidemic
- The scale, scope, and aggregation of data has radically transformed police power, yet most criminal procedure law still exists in an analog world—controlling Fourth Amendment cases involve payphones and microfiche—so there is a fundamental disconnect between fast-moving technology and static law that no one has corrected via constitutional reinterpretation or statute.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- Under current law you have no Fourth Amendment protection over data you share with a third party—including your bank, phone carrier, ISP, and email provider—and the government reserves the right to purchase and read this data in bulk without a warrant, making certain forms of mass surveillance already legal but historically impractical.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - The most important question nobody's asking about AI
- The truth law students are least likely to learn is that policing is not all about constitutional law; they learn the Fourth Amendment and Miranda and think they know the law of the police, but the full law relating to policing requires weighing all the harms and benefits of policing, with law playing a critical role in setting standards.Rachel Harmon
- The Supreme Court has a case this term on geofence warrants—whether locational data around a crime can be obtained from Google, which tracks everyone's phone at all times—and the outcome will test whether the Court adopts a 'digital is different' approach recognizing the world has changed from its analog-era precedents.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- When the Supreme Court interprets new technology under old law—such as requiring a warrant to search a smartphone because of the highly private information it holds—it often pleads with Congress to regulate, but Congress has largely failed to act, leaving courts to stretch a 1791 document to govern modern surveillance.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- The US Constitution, particularly the Fourth Amendment, is the single most important document ever created for protecting human freedom, and its erosion through technology and policy is the core threat to democracy.AI Experts Debate: AI Job Loss, The End of Privacy & Beginning of AI Warfare w/ Mo, Salim & Dave 176
- The fourth amendment (right to privacy) has been effectively abandoned in the US with no public debate or constitutional amendment, and Palantir's expanded data aggregation mandate represents the final step in a post-privacy surveillance state.AI Experts Debate: AI Job Loss, The End of Privacy & Beginning of AI Warfare w/ Mo, Salim & Dave 176