Fair use
A legal doctrine permitting limited use of copyrighted material without permission for purposes like commentary, criticism, or analysis.
As defined in Lex Fridman Podcast #492 - Rick Beato
Other definitions
A legal doctrine permitting limited use of copyrighted material without permission; Kelly notes it was for a time interpreted narrowly ('cramped').
Kevin Kelly on the InevitableA copyright exception, built into US law since the 1700s, allowing limited use of copyrighted works without permission (e.g., for small snippets, criticism, or educational use).
Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
Where it comes up · 5
- Free culture4 claims
- Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/20093 claims
- Kevin Kelly on the Inevitable1 claim
- Lex Fridman Podcast #492 - Rick Beato1 claim
- Sam Altman #21 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Fair use” →
- The DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act) makes it illegal to distribute information about how to circumvent copyright protection technologies, even when the circumvention itself would be legal fair use—for example, Ed Felten's academic paper describing weaknesses in encryption systems, or aibopet.com's code enabling owners to teach Sony Aibo robots new tricks.Free culture
- Fair use is part of the original copyright bargain (dating to the 1700s) giving creators limited rather than absolute rights; one previously unnoticed virtue of fair use is that it functions as a place to solve gridlock—the wider the exception, the easier it is to assemble small fragments (e.g., music samples) into new creative works.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
- A significant portion of the universal library remains inaccessible because many books are not yet digitized—especially orphaned books whose copyright status is uncertain, which libraries hesitate to scan—and scientific journals remain locked behind paywalls.Kevin Kelly on the Inevitable
- The RIAA sued Jesse Jordan, a 19-year-old computer science student who built a search engine to index files on his university's network (of which 25% were music files he did not curate), for $15 million in statutory damages—claiming 'willful infringement' despite the fact that he had done nothing to encourage the sharing of music, and the law cost his family $12,000 to settle despite having clear fair use defenses.Free culture
- Using short music clips within commentary, interviews, or breakdown analysis qualifies as fair use, and YouTube Content ID claims against such use can be fought and won — Beato's lawyer fought 4,000 Content ID claims across his catalog and won every single one.Lex Fridman Podcast #492 - Rick Beato
- Universities and university presses are on the wrong side of the copyright debate—favoring strong copyright and limited fair use—because their fair use policies are set by general counsel offices thinking of the university as a property-rights owner, not by faculty who want the widest dissemination of their work and are paid in prestige rather than cash.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
- Fair use doctrine is not fixed but is defined by what people are actually doing ('reasonable use'); rights holders try to 'brush you back from the plate' to shrink the strike zone, so the only way users retain rights to use snippets is to assert them—and faculty should be more aggressive about asserting educational use.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
- Code (software and hardware architecture) operates as a form of law that enforces copyright control without judicial review or fair use exceptions: once a copyright protection technology is built into hardware or software, it enforces rules absolutely without the flexibility or due process that courts provide.Free culture
- Documentary filmmaker Jon Else could not afford to include a 4.5-second incidental shot of The Simpsons in his film because Fox demanded $10,000 in licensing fees, forcing him to digitally replace it, illustrating how copyright law makes derivative cultural works prohibitively expensive even when the use would clearly be fair use.Free culture
- People who create valuable data deserve some way to be compensated for its use in training AI; specifically artists should be able to opt out of having art generated in their style, and if their style is used anyway there should be an economic model that pays them, even though the exact mechanism (analogous to the CD-to-Napster-to-Spotify transition) is not yet known.Sam Altman #2