Design by Committee
A process where many reviewers and consultants shape a design, often diluting its distinctiveness and slowing decisions.
As defined in #419: Kelly Johnson: Skunk Works
Other definitions
The criticism that a product made by many contributors becomes compromised, bland, or overly complicated because no single vision governs it.
Dylan Field - The Growing Importance of Design – [Founder’s Field Guide, EP.14]
Where it comes up · 2
- #419: Kelly Johnson: Skunk Works3 claims
- Dylan Field - The Growing Importance of Design – [Founder’s Field Guide, EP.14]1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Design by Committee” →
- Design by committee, reviews, and consultations by those not directly doing the job produce nothing very stupid but nothing brilliant either, and major advances come from brilliant concepts developed by other methods.#419: Kelly Johnson: Skunk Works
- Major breakthroughs such as the atomic bomb, Sidewinder missile, and nuclear-powered submarine were achieved by methods other than conventional business, which committee design tends to suppress.#419: Kelly Johnson: Skunk Works
- Strong single-person authority essential to the operation is being eroded by committee and conference control from within and without, and immediate decisions require one person in charge.#419: Kelly Johnson: Skunk Works
- Contrary to fears of design by committee, multiplayer collaboration has produced simpler solutions, as when Kimberly-Clark's team used Figma to cut a pandemic-era order form from 13 fields to five.Dylan Field - The Growing Importance of Design – [Founder’s Field Guide, EP.14]