Counter-elite
A class of ambitious, often highly educated or skilled individuals who are excluded from power positions despite their abilities and aspirations, and who organize to challenge and replace the existing ruling elite
As defined in U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
Other definitions
Excluded ambitious people with education and skills who mobilize against the ruling elite to seize power; typically drawn from overproduced professional classes (lawyers, academics) who face diminished career prospects.
U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
Where it comes up · 3
- U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin9 claims
- Understanding Societal Collapse with Complexity Scientist Peter Turchin2 claims
- Marc Andreessen - The Battle For Tech Supremacy - [Invest Like the Best, EP.410]1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “Counter-elite” →
- Law schools produce lawyers at a 3:1 ratio to available legal positions, creating masses of ambitious, intelligent, rule-breaking counter-elites (citing Lenin, Castro, and Robespierre as examples).U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Revolutions typically involve violence and elimination of the old regime; Russian Revolution saw Bolsheviks sweep away the old elite with many killed; Turchin hopes US revolution will not reach this point but elite replacement is certainly on the counter-elite agenda.U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Many counter-elites do not consciously pursue power for selfish motives; they genuinely believe they are struggling against an unjust social order and seek to reconfigure society toward greater justice and equality, even as they compete for elite positions.Understanding Societal Collapse with Complexity Scientist Peter Turchin
- Trump is an exemplar of a 'billionaire counter-elite'—a wealthy outsider who mobilizes grievances of excluded populations to challenge incumbent elites and secure political position, exemplifying elite overproduction dynamics where frustrated wealthy aspirants use popular mobilization as a tool.Understanding Societal Collapse with Complexity Scientist Peter Turchin
- The most important part of revolution is whether ruling elites are overthrown and replaced by counter-elites, rather than the form it takes (violent or non-violent).U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Political change occurs when a new counter-elite emerges to challenge incumbent elites rather than when the masses act directly, and this explains Trump, Sanders, AOC, Farage, Corbyn, and AfD's rise across democracies.Marc Andreessen - The Battle For Tech Supremacy - [Invest Like the Best, EP.410]
- The 2024 US presidential election represents a kind of revolution—not yet bloody—but one in which the American ruling elites are in danger of being overthrown and replaced by counter-elitesU.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Donald Trump's coalition represents a realignment opposite to the Democratic one: Republicans are reformulating as the party of the working class, and counter-elite figures from across the political spectrum (RFK Jr., Tulsi Gabbard, Elon Musk, Tucker Carlson, mainstream Republicans like Liz Cheney and Dick Cheney) are defecting to either Trump or Democratic side based on ruling-class alignment rather than traditional party loyaltyU.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- When smart, well-networked, energetic, ambitious people are turned into counter-elites by AI job displacement, this is a recipe for disaster because they have the skills to organize revolutionary movements.U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin
- Forces pushing the US toward instability have been building up for more than 40 years, and the US is currently in a revolutionary situation where society is fragile and violent outbreaks may happen, with the 2024 election representing a kind of non-bloody revolution in which ruling elites are in danger of being overthrown and replaced by counter-elites.U.S. On Brink Of Another 'Revolution'; What Happens Next | Peter Turchin