Constitution of Knowledge
Rauch's term for society's decentralized system of norms, rules, and institutions for determining what is true, modeled loosely on the U.S. Constitution and spanning research, journalism, law, and government.
As defined in Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
Other definitions
The system of norms and institutions that liberal societies rely on to keep anchored to a shared reality, requiring structured, rule-bound disagreement rather than mere free speech.
350 - Sharing Reality
Where it comes up · 2
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Constitution of Knowledge” →
- Objective knowledge does not emerge automatically from a free marketplace of ideas; it requires a structured system of norms and institutions—the 'constitution of knowledge'—that compels people to disagree productively, much as the US Constitution pits ambition against ambition, the constitution of knowledge pits bias against bias, both being open-ended systems that never reach a final destination.350 - Sharing Reality
- The constitution of knowledge cannot and need not fix the entire internal information environment; refined over 300 years and staffed by trained professionals, it has always floated and always will float in a larger sea of people who believe bizarre things for largely non-rational reasons—the achievable goal is not eliminating false belief but ensuring that on critical public-policy questions (who won the election, COVID) there exists an arbiter that is both trustworthy and trusted enough to get the job done.350 - Sharing Reality
- The standard 'marketplace of ideas' metaphor is dangerously incomplete because it assumes free speech is enough, when in reality producing knowledge requires getting many settings, institutions, rules, and professionals right—all of which are easy to attack and currently under attack.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The diminishing ideological diversity in newsrooms and academia is a bigger problem than Twitter because the genius of the knowledge system is that others correct biases we cannot see in ourselves; a newsroom of only progressives will forget to ask certain questions and let distortions creep in, harming both reporting quality and credibility.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- Just as markets allowed people to get rich without violence in a non-zero-sum way, the Constitution of Knowledge allows societies to resolve disputes about truth peacefully rather than through wars and killing over what people should believe.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The only system that reliably corrects errors—including its own overreach in narrowing the Overton window—is the constitution of knowledge itself, because it provides incentives to find others' errors and produce better knowledge; the Wuhan lab-leak hypothesis, foreclosed too quickly by mainstream media listening to experts, was reopened and corrected by other journalists (including at the Wall Street Journal) who revisited it months later.350 - Sharing Reality
- Scientism—importing scientific methods into fields where they don't apply as a lazy shortcut—is distinct from science; while the Constitution of Knowledge can organize any kind of debate including theology and moral questions, it cannot adjudicate every dispute crisply because some fields like literary criticism lack evidence people can agree is dispositive.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The Constitution of Knowledge is society's collective system for figuring out what is true and false in a way that respects freedom, sanity, and civility—replacing rulers making decisions about facts with rules that govern how facts are established, much as the U.S. Constitution did for political disputes.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The Constitution of Knowledge rests on four institutional branches—research (academia/science), journalism, law, and government—each fact-based, decentralized, and operating through rules and many institutions, with the concept of a 'fact' originating in law before science.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- Most beliefs of most major religions would flunk the constitution of knowledge because they are not replicable, which is why religion sits outside the reality-based community even though the constitution of knowledge does not govern everything (it doesn't decide what we say at the Thanksgiving table or in church).350 - Sharing Reality