Community Notes
A crowd-sourced feature on X/Twitter that lets users append corrective context to posts they consider inaccurate, as a bottom-up alternative to top-down moderation.
As defined in Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
Other definitions
A crowd-sourced fact-checking feature on Twitter/X allowing users to add corrective context to posts.
Michael Malice
Where it comes up · 6
- 392 - Technology Culture2 claims
- Mark Zuckerberg — AI will write most Meta code in 18 months1 claim
- Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)1 claim
- 349 - Generosity Cynicism And The Future Of Doing Good1 claim
- Elon Musk #41 claim
- Jimmy Wales1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “Community Notes” →
- Saying 'these ideas should be censored' in the passive voice conceals the problem; restated in the active voice—'Person A should be entitled to censor person B'—it becomes clear you are granting someone power to suppress ideas, which is preferable to correct only through more speech and competing ideas.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- Community Notes works because it requires people who have historically disagreed (modeled via AI vector spaces of past ratings, not simply left/right) to agree before a note is shown; combined with fully open-source code and data so any note can be independently recreated and interference would be noticed, this gives it an incredibly good batting average—no incorrect note has survived more than a few hours.Elon Musk #4
- Fact-checking was less effective than Community Notes because it's not an internet-scale solution — there weren't enough fact-checkers and people didn't trust the specific fact-checkers — so a more robust, distributed system like Community Notes is the right approach to content moderation.Mark Zuckerberg — AI will write most Meta code in 18 months
- There are hopeful design signals on X: optimizing for the maximum number of 'unregretted user minutes' targets the reflective mind because regret is a function of reflection, and Community Notes provides crowd-sourced content moderation that quickly slows the spread of the worst viral falsehoods.349 - Generosity Cynicism And The Future Of Doing Good
- Social media's toxic effect on politics is not merely that it lets people scream at each other and rewards anger over happiness, but that the power to carefully curate one's reality and 'do your own research' means we can no longer agree on what reality even looks like, pushing the entire culture toward a kind of universal conspiracy-theorist condition and a nihilistic loss of trust.392 - Technology Culture
- X performs two necessary functions in the current media environment despite its chaos: it surfaces real-time stories and images that mainstream outlets have an incentive not to show—whether for ideological reasons or because they are hard to verify—and its community notes provide a crowdsourced correction mechanism that, while imperfect, is often closer to correct than mainstream fact-checking.392 - Technology Culture
- Twitter's Community Notes feature is valuable because it can elevate a thoughtful, nuanced response under a misleading tweet—Wales reports it has actually changed his mind in cases where he was inclined to retweet something he hoped or feared was true.Jimmy Wales