Coercion
In this context, causing someone to do or not do something against their will—imposing one's will on another.
As defined in Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
Other definitions
Properly defined, either physically forcing someone or presenting a choice where every option leaves them worse off; Satel argues offering a kidney sale is not coercion because declining leaves one no worse off.
Sally Satel on Organ Donation
Where it comes up · 4
- Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #159 claims
- What's Really Driving China's Strategic Objectives? (w/ M. Taylor Fravel & Mike Green)3 claims
- Sally Satel on Organ Donation1 claim
- Gold: The Monetary System's Navigational Beacon (w/ Simon Mikhailovich)1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “Coercion” →
- Critics misuse 'coercion': true coercion means either physically forcing someone or presenting a choice where every option leaves them worse off ('your money or your life'), so offering someone the option to sell a kidney is not coercion because declining leaves them no worse off; what critics actually mean is 'undue inducement'--an offer so tempting it interferes with rational cost-benefit weighing--as distinct from ordinary 'inducement' like a store sale that merely prompts a choice you might not otherwise make.Sally Satel on Organ Donation
- Historically, China has rarely used military force for brute force solutions (simply taking territory), instead using force as an instrument of coercion to bring about political objectives, as evidenced by border wars with India and invasion of Vietnam which were about signaling red lines to Vietnam and MoscowWhat's Really Driving China's Strategic Objectives? (w/ M. Taylor Fravel & Mike Green)
- Whether coercion produces measurable long-term psychological harm is irrelevant to its morality: we condemn coercing or hitting an adult as simply wrong, not because studies show downstream effects, so demanding evidence of harm before objecting to coercing children reflects the same mistaken view of children.Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
- What distinguishes children from chimps (and grants them rights against coercion) is not raw intelligence or working memory but unlimited human creativity—the capacity to form inexplicit conjectures and create new knowledge—which a two-year-old demonstrates by speaking while no animal ever will.Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
- Coercion embodies the theory that 'might makes right,' which is false, so coercion decides issues under an irrational institution and cannot reliably produce correct answers.Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
- The US is implementing a program to disentangle supply chains from China, with TSMC building next-generation semiconductor fabrication facilities in Texas and other areas, which would reduce China's ability to exploit its supply chain role for coercion and make it easier for the US to blockade ChinaWhat's Really Driving China's Strategic Objectives? (w/ M. Taylor Fravel & Mike Green)
- It is not true that most people need mathematics; to the extent they do, they learn it naturally when they need it, and every mathematical discovery was made by someone who found maths a joy rather than being coerced—school coercion is enough to give people a lifelong aversion to it.Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
- An amphibious assault is the only real way China could achieve unification through force, because Taiwan would be able to resist any coercive pressure short of that.What's Really Driving China's Strategic Objectives? (w/ M. Taylor Fravel & Mike Green)
- Anti-rational memes explain why people who suffered coercion as children grow up to coerce their own children: unlike rational memes which thrive under criticism, anti-rational memes survive by disabling their holders' ability to criticize them, so they replicate the same hang-ups across generations.Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
- The claim that coercive schooling instills self-discipline equivocates on the word 'discipline': the self-discipline of a concert pianist or MMA fighter comes from wholeheartedly pursuing their own passion, which is the opposite of disciplining children to suppress their passions and obey—so coercion actually trains children to be unable to pursue anything wholeheartedly.Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15