Braintrust
Pixar's recurring candid feedback meeting of experienced storytellers and directors, which has no authority to mandate changes and helps directors see their work more clearly.
As defined in #34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “Braintrust” →
- Getting the team and its chemistry right is a necessary precursor to getting the ideas right: a good idea given to a mediocre team gets ruined, while a mediocre idea given to a brilliant team gets fixed or replaced, so teams should be judged on how they perform together rather than on individual talent.#34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar
- People who take on complicated creative projects inevitably lose perspective as they fuse with the work, so that where they once saw a forest they now see only trees, and separating the idea from the self is what restores clarity.#34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar
- Pixar's Braintrust is a candid feedback mechanism made of experienced storytellers, with no authority to mandate changes; the director must decide how to respond, because removing power dynamics lets the group focus on the problem rather than the person.#34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar
- Steve Jobs was kept out of Braintrust meetings because his fame and forceful presence would prevent people from speaking candidly, so he gave notes to directors one on one instead.#34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar
- If you give a good idea to a mediocre team they will screw it up, but if you give a mediocre idea to a brilliant team they will either fix it or throw it away and come up with something better.#34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar
- To set up a healthy feedback system you must remove power dynamics so people can focus on the problem rather than the person, because ideas and films become great only when they are challenged and tested.#34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar
- Pixar's early film versions are bad, so the job is to take them from suck to not suck; a new version is generated every three to six months, and films steadily improve with each iteration.#34 Creativity Inc: The Autobiography of the founder of Pixar