Black Box Model
A model whose internal logic cannot be readily explained, so it is judged by its outputs and results rather than by understanding its reasoning.
As defined in #387: Jim Simons Built The World’s Greatest Money-Making Machine
Other definitions
A computational setting where a function is treated as an oracle whose inner workings are unknown and only its input-output behavior can be queried.
99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity
Where it comes up · 3
- #387: Jim Simons Built The World’s Greatest Money-Making Machine2 claims
- #108 Jim Simons (Money Printer)1 claim
- 99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Black Box Model” →
- Simons struggled with trade suggestions from a program he could not explain, calling it a giant black box, and the host argues that the system's opacity was beyond human comprehension and should be judged by results.#387: Jim Simons Built The World’s Greatest Money-Making Machine
- Simons argued that not knowing why planets orbit the sun does not stop us from predicting where they will be, so a system can be trusted for its predictions without a full causal explanation.#387: Jim Simons Built The World’s Greatest Money-Making Machine
- In the black-box (query complexity) model, quantum computers have provable advantages over classical ones, including exponential and super-exponential separations; Aaronson and Ambainis proved a problem solvable with a single quantum query that requires about square-root-of-N classical queries, and showed this is the largest possible gap, though query complexity is a 'perturbation-theory' playground rather than a real-world proof.99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity
- Even after the algorithmic approach began to work, Simons felt it did not feel right because the results came from a black box he could not reason about, illustrating that humans love to play tricks on themselves and that the mind is undefeated by doubt.#108 Jim Simons (Money Printer)