Accounting identity
Equation true by construction, such as Y = C + I + G, that records how output is apportioned but does not establish causation without behavioral models.
As defined in Ricardo Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy 04/27/2009
Other definitions
An equation that is true by definition (such as MV=PY) and therefore contains no causal or economic content on its own.
Austan Goolsbee
Where it comes up · 2
- Ricardo Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy 04/27/20093 claims
- Austan Goolsbee1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Accounting identity” →
- An accounting identity such as Y = C + I + G has too many unknowns to be useful by itself; it becomes powerful only when combined with behavioral equations for consumption, investment, and government spending, which together with market-clearing conditions describe the economy's mechanisms and trade-offs.Ricardo Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy 04/27/2009
- Reis agrees with Roberts that the simple C+I+G undergraduate story is an ex post accounting identity that is true but misleading about causation, because output comes from the bottom up through wealth creation and innovation rather than from a top-down apportioning of spending.Ricardo Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy 04/27/2009
- Much of the confusion in public and policy debates about government spending arises because participants focus on one equation and omit their underlying models; two people can accept the same accounting identity yet reach opposite conclusions because they hold different models of where consumption and government spending come from.Ricardo Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy 04/27/2009
- Policymakers should not design rules off accounting identities like MV=PY because identities contain no economic content; a rule premised on the assumption that shocks resemble previous business cycles (demand-driven) is not robust to changed conditions and should not be pre-committed to.Austan Goolsbee