factual

Smoking-Cancer Debate Resolved By Plausibility

The 1960s smoking-cancer controversy could not be settled by a randomized experiment (which would be unethical), and Fisher argued a hidden gene could make people both crave nicotine and develop cancer; the debate was resolved by bringing knowledge of plausibility to bear—calculating that such a gene would have to make carriers eight times more likely to smoke, a strength judged implausible.

factualpending

Speaker

Judea Pearl

Evidence Quote

“it had to have the strength that the presence or non-presence of that gene would make you eight times more likely to smoke than not smoke. And that was just implausible”

Source

196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:18:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...