normative

Rules Must Be Enforced to Be Rules

Rules have to be enforced to be rules; if they are not enforced at the time and place they are supposed to be, their essential nature as rules is lost. Because baseball had no written steroid policy, enforcement, or consequences while players had massive incentives to succeed, players rationally used steroids, and it is unjustifiable to retroactively brand them cheaters—directly analogous to the illegal immigration debate.

normativepending

Speaker

Bill James

Evidence Quote

“if you don't enforce that rule at the time that you are supposed to enforce it, which is at the place where you are supposed to enforce it, it becomes very hard to say, after the fact, that we--that this--they are a cheater. Because we didn't enforce the rules.”

Source

Bill James on Baseball, Facts, and the Rules of the Game— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...