causal

As-if hypothesis can't isolate what's false

Milton Friedman's 'as-if' methodology fails because any model prediction contains many assumptions — both the maximizing behavior and the model's structure — so when a prediction is falsified you can never identify whether the as-if assumption or some other part of the model is wrong; in practice economics has forecast woefully, predicting nothing significant and then dismissing it as an unexplained shock.

causalpending

Speaker

Mervyn King

Evidence Quote

“macroeconomic models comprise two parts. One is a model which you believe in utterly and totally without any doubt. And the other is a series of stochastic shocks about which you know absolutely nothing.”

Source

John Kay and Mervyn King on Radical Uncertainty— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...