factual

You cannot derive what-to-do from ought

Extending Hume's point that you cannot derive an ought from an is, Clarke-Doane argues you cannot even derive what to do from a question of ought: settling that something is the right or good thing to do does not settle the question of action, because one must still decide whether to do what is good-sub-one or good-sub-two, so questions of action are objective but totally not real — they are what remain once all the facts are settled.

factualpending

Speaker

Justin Clarke-Doane

Evidence Quote

“you can't even derive what to do from a question of ought. You can't even derive a... Okay, so this is the right thing to do, or this is the good thing to do, that won't even settle the question of what to do as a question of action”

Source

137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:21:37 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...