causal

Small-Group Egalitarian Instincts Don't Scale

Humans are an evolved small-group species whose surviving psychological and social instincts favored cohesive, roughly equal-status groups with shared resources; that egalitarian impulse works in a family or camping trip but fails when extended to a large society—a Hayekian 'fatal conceit'—so the socialist inclination is a romantic ideal that does not work at scale.

causalpending

Speaker

James Otteson

Evidence Quote

“The ones that survived are the ones that had a very small, but extremely cohesive and also in many ways an equal status in the community... You had a leader, but wealth and resources tended to be shared within very small margins. And those instincts we carry with us today.”

Source

James Otteson on the End of Socialism— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:27 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...