normative

Moral Luck Undermines Retributive Justice

Much of human morality depends on luck in ways we struggle to integrate: we have all driven distracted or after a drink and gotten away with it, while someone equally negligent kills a child in a crosswalk and is prosecuted; since the punishment of having killed is delivered in full at the moment it happens and such a person will never reoffend, compassion is appropriate even where deterrence may still justify imprisonment.

normativepending

Speaker

Sam Harris

Evidence Quote

“we've all gotten away with that. So, it's just--we are that person. We're just the lucky version of that person. And so, compassion is appropriate.”

Source

Sam Harris on Meditation, Mindfulness, and Morality— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:00 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...